Thursday, April 19, 2018

Who is the racist? What is free speech?

I just got the link and message below from my Fox-News and Donald Trump loving uncle.  Apparently Fresno State is famous again for controversial speech of one of the professors.  You can read more about this at the link.   I had to post a new response, but this is an old issue -- if you scroll down you will see a lengthy post about this same topic when it happened last year. 

https://nypost.com/2018/04/18/this-college-professor-is-happy-racist-barbara-bush-is-dead/
Who's the racist here? Loving compassionate Progressive communist. I wonder if Fresno State                        would invite her to speak. Oh no they would have to go to their safe space. But she has tenure. A                    get out of jail card. It's sickening.


Here's my response:


So what!?  I don't understand the problem.  So the professor was uncivil.  So what.  And disrespectful.  So what.  And wrong.  So what.  What is the problem?

 If you don't like what she said, then argue back and espouse your alternative viewpoint.  Or ignore her.    

I'm not sure what she said was that outrageous anyway.  She was basically attacking the first lady's son.  George W. wasn't the greatest president, and getting us into the war in Iraq under false pretenses was catastrophic -- costing trillions of our tax dollars, and hundreds of thousands of lives (including lives of over one hundred thousand Iraqi civilians). 

Perhaps commenting on the first lady's passing wasn't the place to re-open the attack on George W., but again, its just speech that is perhaps given at the wrong time or context.  We've all heard these statements attacking W. before, so the real problem is that it was done in a new context that apparently bothers people.

  Its not like there was any threat of violence, or any threat to public order in what the professor said.  The professor just ruffled social norms that say that we should show respect for the dead.  They are just social norms.  There's nothing remotely illegal about what the professor said.  She was offensive.  Oh boo hoo.  Our virgin ears.

Do we really want to live in a world where the only free speech is speech that doesn't offend someone? 

If that's the standard, then nobody would have any free speech.  Everything you say is offensive to someone.  

The whole point of free speech is to protect controversial speech.  A free speech law that only protects uncontroversial speech isn't a free speech law, its a horribly-restrictive censorship law. 

 So what bothered me the most is the bullshit statement in the news article by our campus president that the professor's comments were   “beyond free speech. This was disrespectful.”  

Is our campus president saying we have to be respectful when we speak?  To say that is an example of behaving or showing a great lack of intelligence or common sense  It seems like it -- to suggest that free speech must be respectful, that's an example of showing a lack of intelligence or common sense.


Of course, I don't support disparaging speech as a goal, but I realize that all speech can be defined as disparaging by someone.  

What's that, you like puppies?  There are plenty of people that find that unethical and offensive and critical of their way of life. 

 If disparaging speech wasn't allowed, where would we be today?  What would have been the message and legacy of Jesus Christ, Mahatma Gandhi, Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., Rosa Parks, Cesar Chavez, Nelson Mandela, Alice Paul, and other heroes of social change?  

If it were not the right of free speech, would we ever have abolished slavery or given women the right to vote?  One of the truisms of power is that those with power do not willingly give it up.   To quote another hero of social change, 

"Power concedes nothing without a demand. It never did and it never will."  Frederick Douglass, 1857

 If people on the bottom do not even have the right to say anything that those with power find disparaging, then we are truly in a society that believes in repression of speech far more than freedom of speech, and a future that looks increasingly bleak for those who find themselves without money or power in today's society.

Also, if we can't be disparaging, then we also can't call out injustice. 

 I guess next time I mention Hitler, I better not say anything bad because that's disparaging to some people. But to NOT call Hitler a mass-murderer is disparaging to Jews.  There are so many similar examples.  I wrote a book about this with the figure of Columbus.  Each group has a unique view of this historical figure and often these views are diametrically opposed.  To criticize Columbus as guilty of genocide is disparaging to Italians and Spaniards, but to NOT criticize Columbus as guilty of genocide is disparaging to Native Americans.  My view has always been to do my best to hear both sides and let both sides speak freely, even though both sides call the other's perspective an important component of a hate crime.  Now with President Castro's statements, I don't feel comfortable telling anybody's side of the story, because all sides are seen as disparaging by some other side.  Unfortunately, if we are realistic about this, the same pattern happens with all controversial figures and issues.  That's why we need our president to act as a staunch advocate for free speech.   

Do we really want to live in a world where people are fired from their jobs because they say something on social media that others find disrespectful?  Wow, have you been on social media lately?  Its filled with vitriol.  If that's the new standard, then there's going to be an awful lot of people losing their jobs . . .   

 And this is a professor whose job it is to say controversial things to challenge people.

  If professors can't say controversial things, then we might as well just turn professors into robots who can only say exactly what is approved by the government.

 Perhaps robot professors would make more sense than humans.  Why even have people in these positions?  All we need is a group of government censors to write the approved words, and then professors can be fired and lectures can just be a recording that plays  the government-approved messages.  And then students can be graded on their ability to memorize the government-approved messages.  Yep, then we would have a system where everybody only learned the "right things" and nobody had a wayward thought or were even given the ability to think anything offensive.  Perfect.  And then we could all have "free speech" and nobody would be offended. 

By espousing this idea, am I being disrespectful to our social norms of free speech?  Oh no.  Don't tell my campus president or I might be fired. 

---
Feel free to leave your comments below.  I appreciate free speech and debate, even though our campus president doesn't