This was originally published in April of 2017, but was bumped.
"You have the right to free speech as long as you're not dumb enough to actually try it."- Know Your Rights by The Clash
Uncivil discourse has become a popular problem.
(click to enlarge)
How does uncivil discourse (polemics, invective, hate speech) influence actual behavior?
April 2017 was a rough month for Fresno -- Fresno State was in the national news for the professor that tweeted death threats against Trump, and Fresno was in the news for a mass-murderer that targeted four white males. This isn't quite as embarrassing as having one of our students get caught having sex with a sheep on campus, because he was stressed from finals, but its right up there.
The above cartoon was printed in the student newspaper. Yea, we made headlines that time. You can read more and catch a wonderful headline here.
The Professor, the gunman and other' bad hombres'.
I've heard a few people suggest the professor's tweets and the mass murderer are related, and ask the question: Did the gunman do the work advocated by the professor?
The Fresno State professor's statements on Twitter that Trump should be hanged and Trump and other politicians should be assassinated were beyond the pale and I'm glad he's been fired from our university. Regardless of free speech rights and the need for us to be protected so we can teach controversial stances on subjects (and controversial subjects), advocacy of murder and violence should not be tolerated -- especially by someone that is supposed to be an intellectual leader of our community. Of course, there are sometimes when advocacy of killing and violence is acceptable, such as support for war, death penalty and punishment for treason, as just a few examples. That does confuse the issue a bit, doesn't it?
If the professor had said this in the course of a class, and given reasons for the advocating the killing, such as treason, and explained what the treasonous behavior was, I would say that is protected speech and worthy of intellectual debate. But the faculty wasn't in class and there was no charge of treason and no intellectual reasoning to support the violent statement -- the closest thing to that was that Trump's policies were bad for America and ruining our democracy. Advocating violence for political purposes (or with political justification) is unacceptable and the basic definition of terrorism. But again we are ignoring all sorts of people that are employed to kill for political purposes (or with political justifications) such as soldiers, police, or prison guards who pull the lever for capital punishment.
I remember many people saying that Hillary and Barack Obama should be hung for treason. The following image was among the many that were spread on social media,
And this uncivil discourse was not just among outsiders; a Republican candidate for the Florida House of Representatives repeated the charge on Twitter,
Making such a charge, and giving the reasoning behind it, I think would be legally acceptable, but the Fresno State professor didn't do that: Just saying people should be hung and asking for donations for committing such murder as did this professor, all because of policy differences or to assuage some general harm to society is outrageous and worthy of a non-tenured professor losing his job. A tenured professor, I think, would be punished but not fired. Tenure gives you some protection so a firing for your detested speech would be much harder to do. Remember Ward Churchill?
ward churchill
Professor of ethnic studies at University of Colorado, Boulder, and leader of the American Indian Movement, Ward Churchill said, the day after 9/11, that the attack was our own fault because of our bombing of little babies overseas, that the World Trade Center was a legitimate military target because the military is only used when we have world trade interests, and that the people working in the World Trade Center were complicit. He called them "Little Eichmans" to compare them to the Nazi Adolph Eichman who was convicted for crimes against humanity and hanged, even though he didn't hate Jews and was just doing his job as a bureaucrat who ran the trains that took people to the concentration camps. Churchill's statement was widely publicized by the now-unemployed Bill O-Reilly, which caused a national controversy for Churchill's university. Churchill had tenure and was able to keep his job through years of witch hunt investigations and trials, but eventually he succumbed to the pressure and was fired. He tried to take his case to the U.S Supreme Court, but they refused to hear his case.
OK, back to the Fresno case:. Are the Fresno killer and the Fresno professor related? Why did the killer decide to kill now as opposed to some other time? Could the statements advocating violence by the professor have served as some sort of short-term motivation?
How hate speech is related to actual violent actions is hard to know. Often there is not any direct connection, but an indirect connection may still occur, even if people don't acknowledge it.
The killing of 4 whites in Fresno gained national attention, I think, largely because the victims were white. It has also been suggested that the victims were chosen at random, which belies the truth that the victims were chosen because they were white males.
This is another example of how whiteness (and to a lesser extent gender) is invisible in this country -- when whites are targeted it is commonly but wrongly described as totally random. Similarly when males are always the perpetrators (E.g., school shootings) gender is never even mentioned. Many scholars have written extensively on the topic of invisibility for white males, and most describe it as an unearned privilege. Usually they don't talk about privilege in relation to (how we think about) crime and violence, but that relationship is becoming clearer.
Despite the widespread reports that the perpetrator was a terrorist, the Fresno police have repeatedly, and from the very beginning, said this was a hate crime against whites and NOT terrorism, even though the person had a Muslim-sounding name and cried out in Arabic when arrested. Actually we are learning that he wasn't Muslim but was polytheistic. Also, if the gunman had been doing the work of the professor, he would have gone after politicians and Trump, not white males.
Still, I also wonder if there is some relationship between the gunman and the violent rhetoric of the professor, in the same way I wonder if there is a relationship between the right-wing BS spouted by Trump/allies and the rise of violent right-wing militia groups. The difference is that there is no explicit relationship between the professor and the killer, and many members of these militia groups repeatedly and specifically say they are given hope by the rise of Trump. On the opposite side of the political spectrum there are examples of killers who say they were motivated by support for the black lives matter rhetoric. During the 1960's and 1970's members of the American Indian Movement, Black Panthers, Young Lords, and Weathermen are just a few examples of the "liberal" "activist" groups that used violence for political ends. I'm not sure of an Asian focused group, but these groups courted young liberals from all the other major race/ethnic groups -- American Indians, Blacks, Latinos, and Whites. They gained members, motivation, and justification from violent or revolutionary rhetoric. Some members of these groups took part in violent political actions, and some have been charged with murdering police. Many of them have a long list of members murdered by government or political enemies, and members jailed as political prisoners.
cointelpro The counter-intelligence program (cointelpro) part starts at 39 minutes and 20 seconds.
The government created a counter-intelligence program that used the FBI to send in undercover agents to infiltrate these ethnic movements, and used propaganda to instigate inter-movement discord and violence. They also used disinformation campaigns in the national media, and even instigated violence that ended in deaths among the activists, as well as government agents.
And there are other cases where the connection between uncivil discourse and violent behavior have been documented, such as during the November 2016 election, the wacko that believed the fake news story that Hillary Clinton was organizing a satanic child sex ring out of the back of a pizza parlor, and traveled hundreds of miles to the pizza shop with an automatic rifle to stop the crime.
Dylan Roof -- the convicted mass murderer who killed parishioners in a South Carolina Black church said his main motivation was what he had learned from propaganda websites about how Blacks were killing and raping Whites so much that it was a genocide. He felt he was compelled to stop it.
Causes
The violent rhetoric comes from dehumanization of adversaries, which is the same kind of propaganda that we are constantly fed by the national media during and before war.
Slavery was justified for decades by prejudiced beliefs about Black and Native inferiority.
Sociologists teach that prejudice is an outcome and justification for inequality.
Solutions
If we want to stop prejudice, we need to look at the distribution of resources in society. Addressing inequality won't stop uncivil discourse, but likely it will make uncivil discourse less likely. There is a lot of evidence that it is not the lack of money or poverty that causes the most common social problems in a U.S. state or society, but rather it is those states or countries that have the most inequitable distribution of resources that suffer the most social problems. I would guess that uncivil discourse could be added, alongside crime, obesity, smoking, and other social problems as an unintended consequence of inequality.
Another simple solution is censorship. We could censor uncivil discourse, and we could outlaw all public display of bias. This sounds outrageous to us, but probably wouldn't to the French who place all sorts of restrictions on the right to speak about or even wear religious symbols or clothing in public.
I hope the loss of free speech rights is not the end result of our misuse of our freedoms.
The U.S. Supreme Court has even upheld the rights of the KKK to burn a cross on their own land and even to hold a birthday party for Hitler in public spaces within Jewish neighborhoods.
Despite the constitutional protections, free speech is under assault by uncivil discourse. Whether hate speech is free speech is at the cornerstone of this debate.
On one hand, we should not tolerate speech that promotes hate.
On the other hand, if we only allow speech that someone doesn't define as hate, then nobody will have any free speech rights.
This poses a dilemma -- whose speech -- or what speech -- is protected? Should we censor some speech? Whose -- or what -- speech should be censored? If we decide to ban speech that poses a real threat to some individual or group of people, then how do we define "threat" and who gets to decide if some speech is a threat?
Restricting free speech -- to some extent -- has to be part of the solution. I would hope that it would be a small part of the solution rather than a large part of the solution.
How would you resolve this free speech dilemma? How could that solution be put into place?
Another solution is violence. This horrible solution is becoming popular.
Recently there have been violent events on college campuses in reaction to conservative speakers who say they are exercising their rights to free speech. Earlier this year in Berkeley there were violent protests in reaction to a planned campus speech by an offensive writer for Breitbart News. More recently, Berkeley cancelled a speech by Ann Coulter because of concerns over her safety, and even more recently a pro-Trump rally was disrupted by anti-Trump protesters who used violence to break up the pro-Trump rally.. There seems to be a growing belief that conservatives that advocate inequality and white hetero male privilege should be defined as hate speech, and that hate speech not only should be censored but also should be met with violence.
I certainly do not agree with the violent solution advocated by some college students who suggest violence is warranted to stop the hate speech,
Buttressed by an ideology that views “hate speech” as violence and its suppression as self-defense, students increasingly are resorting to the destruction of property and assault to keep conservative speakers quiet.
I would like to remind everyone that the basic definition of a terrorist is a non-government person or group that uses physical violence against citizens to attain a political goal. Are students that advocate violence against what they define as hate speech advocating terrorism? Probably not -- mostly because they are targeting property, but the government increasingly defines the targeting of property for political purposes as a terrorist act as well. I would say that the students are pushing the boundaries of civility and law -- verbally protesting against someone is protected speech, but obviously violence is a crime. The first amendment protects individual free speech from goverrnment intrustion, not from intrusion by other citizens. However, if the university did not sufficiently protect the free speech rights of conservative students, by allowing violent protests to shut down conservative speakers, then that could be interpreted as the government restricting the rights of conservative student groups. Of course, these are complex phenomena, and I am using all of the examples not to give even a full introduction to each but rather I'm using them rhetorically, as is commonly said, 'they are good to think with'Only in a perverse world does violence (and terrorism?) become justified as a solution to hate speech. Obviously violence is not a valid solution to hate speech.
However, that there are so many people advocating this solution shows us the power of the connection between physical violence and hate speech.
Another simple example is to look at the hate crime statistics, which by definition represent the combination of hateful speech and violent crimes.
https://www.fbi.gov/news/stories/2015-hate-crime-statistics-released
Violence between citizens should not be seen as part of uncivil discourse, but censorship and overcoming inequality are two viable solutions. Of course, we might teach people to avoid prejudice but that does not target prejudice at its root cause. Attacking inequality may be especially effective way to reduce both uncivil discourse and violence
Regardless of the solution, I can say with certainty that too often, uncivil discourse shapes (or justifies) violent behavior. Of course the violent behavior must be condemned, but too often we ignore the related uncivil discourse.
Trump and Science
All of the above examples are related to uncivil discourse, and Trump has perhaps been one of the worst perpetrators among mainstream politicians. There are so many different kinds of violent, inaccurate, sexist, homophobic, and prejudiced messages from Trump it is hard to document them all. While most are obviously propaganda, some lies are harder to dissect as they are presented as "facts", such as this,
Documenting all the cases of Trump's uncivil discourse would be interesting, and in fact some intellectuals have already analyzed it and produced some charts comparing Trump to others. Another interesting tool analyzes how we reacted to the election on twitter: https://www.pri.org/ stories/2016-04-29/just-how- uncivil-election-2016-mits- media-lab-has-some-charts-you- should-see
It is interesting to note that while Trump's supporters have a considerably higher rate of uncivil discourse, for at least a portion of the election season, the differences between Trump and the Democratic Party rivals was not a very large difference. There doesn't seem to be a massive partisan divide -- uncivil discourse is used by both republican and democratic supporters.
Lets remember some basic principles of science. The rise of Trump and the rise of hate crimes against Muslims and the rise of white supremacist groups does not mean that Trump's rhetoric was the cause. Correlation does not mean causation. Because Trump's uncivil discourse was not a singular cause of the rise of these groups, does not mean that Trump's uncivil discourse was not one of several causes of the rise of these violent right wing groups. The same can be said for the uncivil discourse in general -- it is not likely ever the singular cause of violent behavior, but, as I've argued in this essay, it certainly could be one of several important causes.
Conclusion
Anyone that thinks that uncivil discourse doesn't matter needs to look at these cases described above and rethink their position. Sometimes the connections between the violence and rhetoric is explicit and sometimes it is not, but I for one don't hesitate to condemn uncivil discourse and acknowledge that it has intended and unintended consequences.
Please leave your educated thoughts about the topic of uncivil discourse below.
-Tim Kubal













My thoughts on uncivil discourse is that it's a rather complex topic. I can't fully understand what the meaning what uncivil discourse through it's use in the text. Based on what I did comprehend is that in censoring all speech that shows bias. Thus creating prejudice and would be the same as condoning violence. Which in my opinion could be true, again, not a fully developed thought yet.
ReplyDeleteI think that uncivil discourse is something that has been occurring for quite some time. So I don't think that it's anything new, but I think that our media has made things get out of proportion. It's a complicated topic to discuss though because in my opinion there almost has to be a line, but where actually is that line? Thats the big question. Uncivil discourse is a big issue in our society today.
ReplyDeleteGoing solely with the definition of hate speech, I would not consider what soldiers, police, or prison guards do as a form of uncivil disclosure. It is their job to maintain peace, or attempt to. I do however agree in considering what our politicians have slathered all over social media as a form of uncivil disclosure. I feel that everyone is entitled to an opinion but not the extent of death threats – you never know who might act on those notions (i.e. the possibility of the FSU professor and the Fresno killer being related?). Sometimes people’s opinions are hard to hear and rough to keep down, but those opinions do not have to define you. You’re personal actions define you and if you do not like what another person said then ignore it because in the end there is nothing you can do about it – suggesting that you do not have to murder someone solely on their opinions. Hate speech is something that happens regularly in our society and is definitely exploited through the media. The difficulty is that while some things we need to hear, something just should not be said.
ReplyDeleteI agree that April 2017 was a difficult month for the families that lost loved ones here in Fresno. Four innocent people lost their lives due to one person's hateful views and crime against Whites. Also, the end of a professor's career for availing his freedom of speech on social media, but the issue is, he was promoting a hateful speech. Depending on how a speech is delivered, it will bring upon either negative or positive consequences to society. Hateful situations like these will continue it's unfortunate that there's always followers or copycats. The profession you hold or the person, title you carry in society shouldn't protect you of your uncivil discourses. One should be held accountable for spreading hate and for what follows!
ReplyDeleteUncivil discourse is clearly a problem however it's proposed solutions may cause even bigger problems long term. Free speech is a freedom that we are allowed to enjoy for a reason. If someone is able to limit what we say in anyway, then that might mean that whoever is putting a restriction on our speech may be our controller rather than our leader. In other words, in a democratic government we would expect that our whole population is able to provide their voice, but if someone is putting a limit on that voice, then we are no longer able to disagree with what we want to and try to make a change. I think the best solution is to worry about the people who are committing the violent acts. Someone might argue that it may be too late, but the truth is that we live in a violent world with violent people, which means that violence will always be present to some extent. Overall, I think your examples are sufficient in supporting and emphasizing your view on the situation.
ReplyDeleteUncivil discourse is a problem that people are too worried about. Mentally ill and unstable people will use whatever message they think is appropriate to justify their actions. Charles Manson was entranced with the Beatles, but that doesn't make the Beatles evil. We should fight for free speech and it should be protected thoroughly. Almost nothing should be censored. People mistake words that offend them, with actual illegal speech that isn't allowed by the constitution. Whenever these people fight so vehemently to censor people that they disagree with they are contributing to the problems in this country, not helping it.
ReplyDeleteMatthew Bevers
Uncivil discourse is only a major problem when it belies a major consequence of action. Hate speech only affects people when it is used in a physical manner to harass or negatively affect someone's life directly. A few extremely negative comments made by one man without any substantial power should just be ignored because it shows how worthless that particular person values his own intellect to make those ideas public. People overly react to comments made giving statements, especially on social media, with little inherent merit substantially more value with real life consequences.
ReplyDeleteUncivil discourse is a poor form of rhetoric and can at times cause bigotry and even violence. However, to band uncivil discourse would be much too complicated because in order to restrict something we must first define it. The concern here is that certain opinions that are outside the majority view would be labeled as uncivil and thus silenced. The support of a variety of views and opinions is what freedom of speech is built upon. However, that does not excuse the detestable nature of some of the comments we see online or hear in society. I believe, that free speech rights should not be hindered but that it is the responsibility of society to point out uncivil discourse and offer a combatant statement to "ignorant" or biased views. In this way all people have the right to express their views. However, they may also be combated by those with different views. Of course local or governmental authorities need to get involved when threats are made or there is a legitimate possibility of danger.
ReplyDeleteI do agree with the statement that uncivil discoursed is an issue that we should try to fix. April of this year has not been good to Fresno at all, due these hate speeches and crimes happening. I do believe that our president could have a lot to do with that issue. As for uncivil discourse, I believe that we can and do have the right to say what we feel. However, I think there should be some extent or limit to that right. I believe that there is definitely a correlation between these hate speeches leading to physical violence happening.
ReplyDeleteHeather Lewis
ReplyDeleteSOC-111
I think that uncivil discourse is a huge issue that needs to be addressed based on the evidence that was given or at least try to minimize it. I also believe that trying to put restrictions on speech is not a very good idea because of several reasons. There should be people who can give a speech without the speech going towards saying that someone needs to be murdered or hurt to try and pull their own agenda on someone else. Yes, I agree that things are happening in Fresno and else where that should be looked at, but not with trying to restrict free speech. There are just too many things that could go wrong with trying to quiet down free speech, but there are things that intellectual people should know not to do such as saying to hang President Trump on Twitter.
Due to uncivil discourse the topic of free speech becomes highly controversial. Some people believe that everyone is entitled to speak about anything they desire, whether it is appropriate or not, while others believe that the given right of free speech should not be misused and people shouldn't speak about things that would offend others. Should there be an in-between when it comes to free speech? Whether we believe it or not we live in a world where prejudice is apparent everywhere. We tend to judge other people based on their gender, race, ethnicity, family background, etc. This leads to the connection between hate crimes and prejudice. People tend to place one type of race or ethnicity into a good or bad category. Such as Muslims or Sikhs being placed into the category of terrorists. We cannot assume that if one person of a particular race committed a crime then everyone from that race will do just the same. Being citizens of the United States we take for granted that we live in a highly advanced and developed country. Then why is our thinking so narrow-minded if the country we live in is so advanced? Simply addressing the problem of prejudice will not make it go away. We must take action on it and the first step is to stop jumping to conclusions based on one first impression.
ReplyDeleteUncivil discourse is what the current president used as his campaign for presidency. When I first heard what was coming out of his mouth I began to worry. Not because I believe anything that comes out of his mouth, but because of all the hate crimes that would happen by his fan base as a result. On the other hand, that does not mean that I believe anyone should be censored. If we are forced to only speak what is permissible, we no longer have freedom. Therefore, our civil rights would be violated.
ReplyDeleteI truly believe that every individual's right to freedom of speech is something that should be protected at all cost. However, on the other hand there are those who cross the line by including unnecessary things. Without a doubt it seems clear that verbally threatening someone is crossing that line. Some may argue that the whole point of speaking freely has just been ripped away, but that is not true. Saying you’re going to kill someone, or throwing racist remarks is just something that shouldn’t be tolerated. Many opinions based on this issue would possibly change if an event such as this happened to somebody's children, siblings, or family members. All in all it clearly isn’t right, but it’s sad to say that we will not see the end of this anytime soon.
ReplyDeleteRocio Chavez
ReplyDeleteSoc. 111
In all honesty, I had never thought much about the topic of uncivil discourse, but after reading Dr. Kubal's essay I was stunned. It seems like uncivil discourse happens all around us whether it directly impacts our lives or not. Now that our city of Fresno has gained large media coverage it is hard to imagine where these types of situations are not taking place. I feel like when a person uses threats or forms of hate speech, it serves as fuel for those who already had the same mindset to commit the acts or be violent. If uncivil discourse is inevitable and cannot be directly controlled, I am sure that horrible things such as mass murders or full blow racist acts will continue to be a burden to our society. In the end, telling someone what they can and cannot say would be in violation of our right to free speech. I think we can just hope for others to use this right wisely.
Pavy Her
ReplyDeleteSoc 3
I think there is no relation between the gunman and the professor. What they both dd was wrong. Randomly killing innocent people and advocating to kill the President. No one should be advocating to kill anyone. It is not right to take another's life for unsupported reasons. I think uncivil discourse can lead to many problems.
Khao Lee Xiong
ReplyDeleteSoc 3
Uncivil discourse is an huge issue that our society should fixed. I believe that everyone have their own freedom of speech and say what they want to say, although there are some things that should not be stated like profanity or threats. Everyones' freedom of speech is important and it's something that should be protected, but people should know the boundaries when to stop too. However, I do also believe that this year April was one of the worst, how there's so many hatred and horrible article about about students and professors in Fresno. Things like this should but not be publish or stated, and I believe that President Trump should do something better to prevent these situations to happen.
Uncivil discourse is here to stay and whether we like or not, it is not going to change. People with outrageous remarks, such as the former Fresno State professor about hanging President Trump, are not going to change anytime soon. Along with social media and the ability to express ourselves throughout technology, uncivil discourse will always be present. Now is it harmful? I want to say no and yes. I believe an educated individual will evaluate all of his or her information and data before making such a claim publicly; however, we as the audience need to take their opinions, as just as opinions. We as individuals need to question everything that is be told or given to us. Everyone is entitled to their opinions regardless of how outrageous the statements maybe. What can be done from uncivil discourse is allowing both sides to formally express or voiced their opinions and audience needs to be informed to not stir negative emotions from either sides. With proper facilitation people opinions will be heard but not influence the audience to do something that will jeopardize their safety and the law.
ReplyDeleteUncivil discourse will continue to occur as long as people are unhappy. Situations mentioned above, such as the professor's comments on his social media should not have taken place due to him being an intellectual who does have the position to talk about these political issues, but in a different way. That being said, I don't agree with the way this professor handled his distaste of Trump, but it was his personal opinion, and I don't believe he should have been attacked the way he was. Additionally, the other instances spoken about all seemed to have violent consequences, for example the Fresno shooting or Dylan Roof. These people could have taken to social media to state their opinions, rather than murdering people. Sometimes civil discourse is better than the violent crimes these people committed.
ReplyDeleteBianca Martinez
mon/wed class: 330
Uncivil discourse can be seen as a very controversial issue. It seems to have been a huge issue in the Fresno area within the last few months with the incident involving the professor who got fired and the murders. I find it to be a horrible thing for the media to say the murders were "random" just because they were white males. If it were another race I believe there would have been a lot more uproar of racial targeting. I also agree that the professor deserved to get fired due to his actions. He would have been fine if he brought up the topic in the classroom and had legitimate evidence to support his claims but he publicly announced these threats on social media to the public. There has just been a lot going on in Fresno lately and we need to come up with a solution.
ReplyDeleteCorina McConnell
Sociology 111
Stephanie Uriarte
ReplyDeleteI don't believe that Fresno States professors comments and the mass murder is related at all either. I feel that the professor was wrong for tweeting such horrible things. Many people don't agree with the current president's views but they don't go online and post death threats. As a professor he should've known better. I believe that the freedom of speech we have in this country should be protected for every individual but to a certain extent. Hate speech should not be tolerated. I understand that if people are forced to only speak what will be considered permitted then we are not truly free.
Sandy Vongthong
ReplyDeleteSoc 111
From what I have read in the article, uncivil discourse seems to be negative especially if it can harm individuals. All individuals including public figures and community leaders should be aware of the things they say or post on social media as the message they are conveying can provoke others to commit violence. As a possible solution, I believe there should be some limitations in uncivil discourse in order to prevent others from getting hurt. At the same time, certain restrictions may be viewed as a violation of Freedom of Speech. While, I am not suggesting the government should control everything we say or do like North Korea, I feel our society will be more safe and benefit from limiting uncivil discourse.
When I read this article, it had exposed me to many news I have not heard of from the goat story at Fresno State (really disturbing) to pizza parlor story involving Hilary Clinton, but I digress. After reading this article, I agree that there may not be simple solution to uncivil discourse and it is a matter of opinions rather any form of speech is free speech.
ReplyDeleteUncivil disclosure is a serious problem in our country because people are negatively affected by it. I do think solving this issue would be difficult because by restricting speech that would show that one side of the argument is supported more than the other. This would also make freedom of speech no longer free because people would only be limited to speaking about the the things that are allowed to be said. However, I do think that threats should not be tolerated and counted as freedom of speech. Because when someone makes a threat they are no longer only speaking their opinions but are wanting to physically do what they are saying. That is what should be considered crossing the line with freedom of speech.
ReplyDeleteWhile reading this article, I realized there were a lot of things going on at my school that I did not know about. I didn't know the extent of what the professor did and the full story about the student and the goat. People should be aware of what they say, from this is can be miss interrupted, I don't believe that the murders and the professor are the same thing, the words made seem similar but they are not the same. I feel people should watch what people say, not all speech should be freedom, maybe it would stop uncivil discourse.
ReplyDeleteAfter reading this post about uncivil discourse, I've realized how much of an impact hate speech has on society. For instance, sharing your opinion about a topic in a negative way can get you in huge trouble like the professor from Fresno State did. Although he did go too far in his feelings towards Trump, I feel like he should not been fired. Personally, he was just speaking his own free will and not acting upon what he shared on social media. Overall, to avoid social issues, I agree that there should be limits when it comes to free speech before serious matters take place.
ReplyDeleteReading this post about uncivil discourse and hate speech made me think about how this happening around the world not only in our country today. It made me imagine being in an individual's position, who's suffering from racist treatments, threatening language, or any type of hate speech. As an Hispanic I've seen how much hate and criticsm our race and other minority groups have received. I feel that hate speech is getting out of control now more than ever before, and if it doesn't stop things will only get worse. Our rights of freedom to free speech are not as important to the government, since it is getting harder to control the rebels we have today.
ReplyDeleteAfter reading this post about uncivil discourse, it has shown me how much of a problem hate speech can cause. Hate speech can cause violence throughout masses of people and to them it is a "solution" to the problem that they are angry about. The professor that is discussed in the post was my teacher for this semester and it was a shock to me that he was someone different outside of the classroom and I did not agree with what he said because even though he was expressing his feelings, they could have started a movement and he would be responsible. Over these past few years as discussed, hate speech has become a more popular way to express how one individual is feeling and it has began to get out of hand from what we can see on the news and right at our won campus.
ReplyDeleteI agree that uncivil discourse is a serious and complicated problem that we currently face. Coming up with logical, effective solutions is even more complex. I have seen that many Americans take pride in their right to free speech. I can see how it will become a problem if we begin to place restrictions or censor hate speech, since it begins to limit your freedom of speech. As my government and politics teacher once told us, "Your rights should be limited once they interfere with mine." If you exercise your right to free speech (or hate speech, specifically) and they interfere with mine, then there is a problem. I definitely agree with free speech. It is your right to say what you think and feel. The issue comes when you decide to act upon your hateful beliefs and begin to harm others.
ReplyDeleteVanessa Naranjo, Soc 3 Section 5 Monday 11 am
reading this post gets you thinking about the two sides of a story. saying this what you see on the news about terrorism and all the bad comments and other remarks people make about certain people as "hate speech" is unjustified. it especially shocked me to read that one of our own at our university was involved in this situation and took part in it. there is a correct way to express how you feel towards something but after reading this I never knew what other level people took this words and how they can affect peoples lives.
ReplyDeleteJose Lopez, Soc 3 Monday 11-11:50 A.M.
Leslie Morales
ReplyDeleteSoc 3
Uncivil Discourse is a problem in today society as it has been for decades. The problem i that social media is allowing this to get too far and out of hand because people post or say things without them thinking about the possible consequences. Uncivil Discourse can be harmful and violent. This stems from several things. Censoring our freedom of speech takes a bit of our rights and even though it could be beneficial, it could cause other problems.
In my opinion, uncivil discourse happens everywhere and all the time. Whether people purposely intend to threaten and have violence related consequences or expect there to be no consequences at all, there most likely is someone out there that will read those comments or listen to those comments and it have an affect on them. Some may take it to a far extent, so it is important to be aware of how things are put in to context. I agree that taking action and approaching this problem is something that is highly need but the question is how do we recognize uncivil discourse and what can we do about?
ReplyDeleteUncivil Discourse seems to be a controversy topic. I am a bit unsure of what it really means, but in my opinion it seems to relate to racism, prejudice, hate speech, violence and many more things. Its overall a complicated topic. The things that have been happening in Fresno come to a shock to me becasue on the news you see all the madness going on in the world and all of the unexplainable things people are doing and to see that it is happinging in a small town like Fresno is crazy. Anything can happen at any moment anywhere though. More people are becoming more mentally unstable and this is causing them to act out. I don'e mean it in a racist way, but Whites are the problem. White privlage is real and it sucks because they thing they can do whatever they want and get away with it. Because they are doing all of these horrific things, people see that they are getting away with it with very minimal punishment so they want to do it. I say it is a bandwagon effect. People are starting not to care what they say to the world. They think their words don't hurt people when in reality it could just be angering them and pushing them to do something horrible. Hate speech will lead to violence. And it is absolutley mind boggling that our own President takes a part in this. In my opinion his actions and words make white people feel that what they are doing is okay and if things saty like this and don't change, this world will be in a whole lot more toruble.
ReplyDelete-Fabiola Ramos
Soc 3 MON 11-11:50 AM
Uncivil discourse is a problem in today's society. Especially with an outlet such as social media, people have become immune to speaking with such hate and disrespect. Uncivil discourse may lead to further violence and hate speech/crimes towards one another. "Free speech is not hate speech", is the saying that goes. Although what President Donald Trump is doing unlike anything that would be considered a rational decision, we the people have a moral obligation to respect one another even if we disagree with the action that another is doing. Leaving a "hate speech" over social media is not setting a good example for our future generations to come, which can in turn be problematic for our country.
ReplyDelete-Omar Wafa
SOC 3- MON (11-11:50 am)
Uncivil discourse is a controversial topic. There are obviously ways to solve it, however that does not mean that all of those factors should be implemented. For example, I do not believe that violence should be something that people must come to in order to realize the fate of the world or economy or politics. I believe that a huge part of the uncivil discourse taking place in the world today have to do with what people are teaching children in this day and age. Children, especially millennials, live in an era where "everybody wins" and things and simply handed to them. They also live in the age of social media where they grow up judging others and becoming more antisocial due to communicating mainly through cell phones and computers. In my opinion, this can lead to more violent behaviors and may be a big reason that uncivil discourse has been on the rise.
ReplyDelete-Brittany Clegg
ESSAY PART
ReplyDeleteUncivil discourse is a problem in our society in today’s world. It is a form uncivil gesture, or “hate speech”, towards another person. It can also be thought as something or someone who lacks civility or “good” manners. All forms of uncivil discourse are being used, especially with outlets such as social media, and other news platforms. Many people have become immune to the idea of uncivil discourse because of how common it has become. For example, the article on the blog about the Fresno State professor’s rant on Twitter about President Donald Trump and how he should be “hung” or killed. Although the acts that President Trump has displayed since the start of his presidency can be rather unfathomable, there is no justification for someone like a professor, whom is a leader in the community, speaking in such a way as to set a bad example to future generations. Uncivil discourse may cause major harm towards the future generations that our world holds responsible for. It may also lead to further hate speech/crimes, and other violence that may hinder the prosperity of our world. In an article, titled, “Here’s how racism and uncivil discourse can affect your health”, by the Washington Post, the article mentions about the many adverse health effects that it has on a person mentally and physically. The article mentions about the effects after 9/11 that ensued with the hate crimes towards the Muslim people. These examples show how much of a harmful impact that “incivility” may have towards our society. The more that people use such hateful and harmful words towards another person because of their political or social differences, the more likely a person will respond in the same manner, causing an overall hostile environment.
It is sad to see so much hate in the world caused by what one person says or posts. It's a difficult problem to solve. We have people acting out in violence because of what one persons opinion is and that opinion is protected by the first amendment--whether it's valid or not or whether the person intended to be hurtful or not. I don't know how to solve it and I don't think we will ever be able to solve it. I think taking away individuals freedom of speech would just add more problems. Maybe if social media was able to censor all of the fake news and fake statistics then I believe there wouldn't be as much violence going on today. I think part of reducing uncivil discourse resulting in violence is teaching people that our country allows freedom of speech which means people can pretty much say whatever they want. So sometimes what they say is going to be mean and hurtful and you're not going to agree with it--and you have the right to tell them that--but you don't have the right to act violently against someone else because they expressed their protected opinion.
ReplyDeleteMegan Clays
Soc 3 9:00-9:50
uncivil discourse causes biases in arguments. By reading this essay I realized that most uncivil discourse is frowned upon because people who see free speech as a way to be prejudice see it as a right that's usually one sided. For instance the kkk showing a display for Nazism by a Jewish synagogue.
ReplyDeleteUncivil Discourse Essay
ReplyDeleteUncivil discourse is definitely harmful to society. It usually consists of what is called “hate speech” and can sometimes turn extremely violent. It is evident that this type of behavior needs to stop. However, a lot of us have become used to seeing all these types of incidents in the media. Whether it be the riots that took place at UC Berkeley over a conservative guest, or even something more extreme, such as a hate crime shooting. Uncivil discourse is harmful because it puts us at risk of becoming victims of a hate crime. I believe that the riots that occurred at UC Berkeley were absolutely ridiculous, because conservatives should still be able to express their opinion, regardless of who else agrees. Instead of forming riots, why not have a meaningful debate about different points of view? I definitely believe in freedom of speech, and the ability of expressing ourselves to others. However, it is different once someone decides to discriminate against someone else because of different ideologies, or different skin color or religion. That is what I have a problem with.
For example, a news article from Washington’s Top News titled “Jewish community reacts to spike in religious hate crimes” talks about the rise of hate crimes, particularly against the Jewish community. According to the article, in Montgomery County, there seems to be more anti-Semitic hate crimes than any other type of hate crime, despite Jews making up only 3.1 percent of the population. The most common type of hate crime reported against the Jewish community was vandalism and graffiti. In public restrooms and public recreation areas, many swastikas have been noted. This cannot be considered freedom of speech, since it is obviously hurting the Jewish community. This type of hate seems to stem from the Holocaust, which is one of the most tragic hate crimes that has occurred. Jews in Montgomery have every right to be comfortable in their neighborhood without feeling fearful or threatened. We should be focusing more on these types of hate crimes, instead of trying to censor a conservative author.
News Article Link
http://wtop.com/montgomery-county/2017/04/jewish-community-reacts-to-spike-in-religious-hate-crimes/
There is a lot of controversy related to this topic. This section made me think about a lot of "what if's," and how things are changing in society. Honestly it makes me sad and somewhat frightened about the way things are happening not only here locally but in the country itself. If a person is entitled to free speech, I don't think we should get judged, yet alone receive death threats because you expressed how you felt. I think social media has a lot to do with the way people are acting and handling certain issues. And I was really shocked reading about what the student did with an animal. That to me is wrong, what the teacher said freely I think shouldn't be a big deal. I've had professors speak badly about Trump and they haven't received any death threats. Our world is getting crazier by the minute so we have to be very cautious.
ReplyDeleteUncivil discourse is a serious issue that needs attention and action. It is becoming increasingly common in our society due to the recent presidential election, popularity of social media, and controversial topics that continually unfold. I agree with many of the statements within the blog; I agree that the Fresno State professor should have been punished for his comments about hanging President Trump, that there may be a correlation between hate speech and violent crimes, and that a solution needs to take place. The increasing number of violent outbreaks is highly concerning, especially hearing about incidences in Fresno. Prejudice and inequality play major roles in civil discourse and violence, and this blog clearly demonstrated the need for prevention and intervention strategies.
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion, there is no place for uncivil discourse in our society. There is no problem, or disagreement that cannot be solved with calm, cordial conversation. A lack of critical thinking skills and open mindeness hinders any chance people have at maintaining civil conversation. We act on our emotions without thinking. At first, I have to admit, I did not think professor Lars should have been reprimanded for his tweets. However, I thought about it more and realized that I would have been outraged if a professor said the same things about our former president Barack Obama,a president who I have the upmost respect for. It occurred to me that I would indulge this crassness, as long as it was for a guy I did not particularly care for, which is not right. However, the fact that I was able to come to this conclusion was due to my years of higher education. Along with the solutions stated in the article, uncivil discourse can be remedied through education.
ReplyDeleteCivil discourse is probably the issue that needs more awareness for people to accept it as a problem or a viable threat to social equilibrium. Even though there are many ways people exhibit their unhappiness with policies and other issue using many different media like social, political or personal but if it not detected and put stopped to it then soon it takes the form of violence. We are aware that it is used on many occasions but the it's limit will decide the consequences faced by the individual. Like Trump has authority so his civil discourse is most likely to be neglected and often never taken action against due to his authority whereas same does not hold true for a college professor of a state university. truly said as long as this inequality exist in the society civil discourse will follow but it is in our hands to control it or exhibit in a proper manner not violating other people's rights.
ReplyDeleteAfter reading, I understand where people are coming from while discussing uncivil discourse. From how the killing of four white men in downtown Fresno from a Arab killer. Being more of a killing based on hating white people rather than an act of terrorism. Then concluding with the issue of the Fresno State professor tweeting his emotions on the newly president Donald Trump. Discussing how the president should hang himself, with the end result of the professor losing his job. Also how everyone is entitled to free speech on whether or not others are okay with what is being said. Having others say hate speech is not the same as free speech, when any type of public speaking is allowed. Every of it is towards a specific ethnic or political group. This is what I read based on uncivil discourse.
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion, uncivil discourse is a serious social issue that shouldn't be overlooked. After reading this article I now have a more in depth sense of what uncivil discourse is. With social media being more actively used by many, it is common for people to be informed with fake news and have acts of hate break out. Everyone has the right to free speech but there is a certain limit to what can be said. I think that people should have free speech as long as they are not hurting another individual. With this being said the professor was indeed wrongful to say those thing against president trump, in my opinion.
ReplyDelete-Yarehyzi Zuniga-Chavez
soc 3, 11-11:50am
After reading this article, I understand that uncivil discourse is a topic that our society needs to look more into and that it is a serious issue. Within recent years having outlets of communication (such as Twitter) becoming more popular, I believe that has added more fuel to fire because it gives anyone the ability to post their threatening speeches, not just the ability to post their thoughts about the weather today or what happened on their favorite television show. Everyone deserves the right to have free speech, but when things get out of hand like they did with the professor here at Fresno State, it should definitely be taken seriously. I believe that President Castro did the right action by letting the professor go because what he did was not right and if he had students that looked up to him a role model and those students saw that, they wouldn't think of him as highly as they did anymore.
ReplyDelete-Soc 3 MW 9-950
After reading this article, it has given me more perspective of what's going on in our society. I knew about the Fresno state professor and the mass murders, yet I wasn't too sure on the details. Uncivil discourse is something that the public should be focused on stopping. Hate speech is a large part of uncivil discourse and the people who take part in this action only do it because they are low lives and can hate on people behind a computer or social media account. The only way to stop hate speech is for every person to just stop spewing our hate comments; which is impossible. Hate speech, gender equality and race are the largest controversies in our country today and have been in the past and there is no way of stopping it. Some people in this world want to peace and equality and I hope that I will be alive to see that one day. Yet in reality, people can't keep their nasty opinions to theirselves and others cannot support others realistic opinions. For example, I cannot agree with you that the murder and the professor are related because I believe things happen as a coincidence all the time, but I respect your opinion because neither of us really know if that is true or just an assumption. Lastly, being white and seeing these crimes makes me upset. I know not all white people are bad and not all blacks and bad. I strongly believe that there is good and bad in every race. Yet the problem is is when a person of color does something bad is posted all over the media but when a white person does something it's most likely pushed under the rug. That is not my fault and not half of our countries fault. It's particular people that work in the media that give blacks and whites a bad name. When will this stop? Probably never because it is so hard for people to put their opinions aside to get along for the sake of our country.
ReplyDeleteAriana Cuaron Soc 3
ReplyDeleteI do not think that the gunman and the professor are related in anyway. I completely agree with the picture of a man with a sign that says "Hate speech is not Free speech". In no way is hate speech at all the same as free speech. Hate speech is not acceptable and what the professor said is considered hate speech and he should be punished for his words. Hateful words can influence others to do horrible things...although I still do not believe that the two incidents were related.
After reading this article, It made me question our community and if I really knew what was going on. I've heard about all the incidents described above and Honestly thought that the goat one wasn't true and that they have exaggerated the one about the professor but after reading about the details about these incidents I cannot believe of what fresno has come too. Hate speech is and issue that has been going on through the years but lately it has increased and has gotten more violent. People will ALWAYS have something to say regardless of it being good or bad, it's what we believe our "freedom of speech" is. Remember that if you're trying to prove a point then you must have reasons behind your conclusion. Like the article said maybe if the professor had given reason behind his thoughts then he would still be employed but because he didn't it was considered a threat, leaving him without a job at Fresno State. Social media has a huge part in uncivil discourse, it has given people a huge platform to announce what they want to anyone they want. It's in the matter you decide to share your information that will conclude if it's harmful to others of not. This article sure opened my eyes to see of what our community has come down to. Fresno should work on getting getting acknowledged for it's good deeds. Hate speech as well as uncivil discourse may never end but there should be more information give to the public about its consequences and what can happen.
ReplyDelete-Rosa centeno
Mon: 11am
Matt Martinez
ReplyDeleteSociology 3
Uncivil discourse is certainly an issue within our society and one that needs to be addressed more from each side of the aisle. Both conservatives and liberals maintain huge usages of uncivil discourse, which is making America a harder environment for us to voice our opinions. All too often, when somebody is simply trying to state and share an opinion that they may have, that opinion is shut down as "hateful" or "offensive" when really its just an opinion that somebody disagrees with. America has become too polarized and divided along certain political lines, which has resulted in an increase in uncivil discourse, and this is an issue.
Uncivil discourse is definitely a problem in the Fresno county and our society as a whole. Trending advancements such as technology and social media is a big opportunity for people to voice their opinions and personal bias. On occasion, these thoughts can be taken too far to the point where it becomes disrespectful to others and their opinions. Uncivil discourse may lead to further violence and hate towards other citizens which ultimately will do more harm than prove any point. Every individual should have a moral obligation to respect each other even if we are in disagreenment. Leaving a hateful comment or post over social media is not a good way to set the stage for future generations or help our country advance in any way and could eventually be the reason for the downfall of the country one day.
ReplyDeleteJennifer Ortiz
Sociology 3
Karissa Bedard
ReplyDeleteUncivil discourse if a problem in our society. People use technology as a way to say what they want to say even if it is offensive. People take things way too far and can cause threat, hate, and violence against one another. Even though we have the right to voice our own thoughts and opinions we needs to take into account other peoples feelings and be able to show them respect. Social media is a big factor on how people have been acting, they think just because they are behind the screen they are not doing any harm and this needs to change.