Sunday, May 7, 2017

Jayden Garcia. Why uncivil discourse is bad.

Jayden Garcia

Soc 3. M,W 9-9:50

Professor Kubal

7 May 2017

Why Uncivil Discourse is bad

            Uncivil discourse is becoming an increasing issue in today's society, with a new President and ever-changing social norms it seems that uncivil discourse had just become a way of life in modern America. Based on my knowledge and readings, uncivil discourse is the discussion of topics in an uncivilized way or manner. Uncivil discourse can lead to riots and violence, I think that some people forget just how hurtful words can be to some people. While some people may see this as their right to free speech, others see it as hate crimes and discriminatory. Uncivil discourse is something that has and will continue to affect people unless something is done about it.

            In today's society we see uncivil discourse take many forms, the most common one is racism. Racism is all around us and no matter how hard we try to escape it or act like it isn't there the more it feels like we hear about it. In an article released in The Guardian, a British daily newspaper, the author discussed how Richard Spencer a known white supremacist was punched in the face while being interviewed. This incident sparked a rise in social media, the most noticeable was a "punch a nazi" meme that circulated throughout various social media websites. It was noted that many people were laughing and saying that Spencer deserved it calling him a racist and saying horrible comments about him. While being a white supremacist may not seem right to most people that still does not give them the right to show racist comments back and say demining things about Richard Spencer. Maybe in his mind he is just voicing what he feels is right.

            Uncivil discourse is unfortunately and evident part of our society. The continuous use of uncivil discourse in our society will continue to lead to social barriers and increased racism. Many people view uncivil discourse as just another part of our right to free speech, but when it causes social injustice is it still just exercising freedom of speech? Uncivil discourse is not tolerable and there should be something done about this, there is some uncivil discourse that should be considered hate crimes.

 

https://www.theguardian.com/science/brain-flapping/2017/jan/31/the-punch-a-nazi-meme-what-are-the-ethics-of-punching-nazis

 

Mayra Rodriguez Uncivil Discourse: UC Berkeley

Mayra Rodriguez

Professor Kubal

Sociology 3

7 May 2017

Uncivil Discourse

Article URL: http://www.cnn.com/2017/02/01/us/milo-yiannopoulos-berkeley/index.html

Uncivil discourse has become a problem lately, and mostly in our country. Many people have their own opinions and express them in their own way, but at times do not realize that the way that they are expressing themselves is not in a civil manner. One primary example would be the reaction that people were giving after the Presidential election of Donald Trump. It was clearly evident that many people were disappointed and did not like the idea of having him as a president, however it was unnecessary for all the violence that occurred at the UC Berkeley. The protest was supposed to be a peaceful protest, but instead was turned into something very violent. It initiated all because people were against all the racism that came after the presidential election and they were no longer going to take any more of it. The way that these protesters approached the situation was very uncalled for and very uncivilized. Not only did they cause damage to school property, but they also hurt many people along the way in a very physical manner. It is understandable that they had the right to stand up for what they believed in and stood up for themselves, but the drastic measures were very uncalled for. Just like the Fresno State professor received consequences for his twitter posts, which possibly put in danger the life of the president, these students reactions showed that they did almost the same thing when expressing themselves. Uncivil discourse seems to be getting much worse especially if inequality in every aspect keeps continuing. Uncivil discourse will only worsen the situations that we are in instead of fixing them, which comes to show that it is a continuing problem.

Bibliography

Park, Madison, and Kyung Lah. "Berkeley Protests of Yiannopoulos Caused $100,000 in Damage." CNN. Cable News Network, 02 Feb. 2017. Web. 08 May 2017. <http://www.cnn.com/2017/02/01/us/milo-yiannopoulos-berkeley/index.html>.

Skyler Lee, Uncivil Discourse


A Citizen's Responsibility to Combat Uncivil Discourse
Uncivil discourse decreases the quality of rhetoric in professional, academic and social communication. It is a blemish to logic and draws attention away from legitimate arguments. However, due to the broad and nearly undefinable nature of the term "uncivil discourse", it would be difficult (if not impossible) to restrict these statements altogether.
Incidents of uncivil discourse occur daily and are not out of place in modern society. However, occurrences of uncivil discourse seemed to run rampant during the 2016 Presidential elections. There were rash words from both sides, straddling the line between argument and insult. These statements however did not just apply  from one party to the opposing party. They often occurred within parties. An example of this is displayed by President Donald Trump's statement about Republican presidential candidate Ben Carson.
Trump used Carson's own description of his past bouts of temper as a young man against him. He hinted that his "pathological" temper was something that could not be cured. However, the part of the statement that began to be uncivil was when Trump compared Carson's fault to "a child molester." He asserted that there was essentially no cure except a cure that he said he did not want to mention. This could be considered uncivil discourse as it hinted that Carson was at the very least, comparable to a child molester.
This statement had nothing to do with the issue at hand. Rather, it was a direct attack on Carson's character, one that held no factual pretense. Essentially, Trump connected the label of child molester to his competitor's name in the minds of the public. He made Carson out to be "pathologically diseased" simply because the man admitted to a weakness of his past ways. This statement had nothing to do with Carson's policies. It only aimed to label him as an unqualified presidential candidate.
This qualifies as uncivil discourse because it is a brash and unfortified statement. However, politicians, government officials and citizens make such statements on a day to day basis. To identify which statements deserve censorship would be a monumental task. In order to accomplish this, the term "civil discourse" would first have to be defined. People would have to answer questions such as "If no violence is hinted at, is it still uncivil?" and "Do we censor every civilian post or just those that imply racist, ignorant or absurd assertions?" Here the freedom of speech and uncivil discourse meet face to face. While, uncivil discourse is harmful, it can not combat the power of free speech granted to citizens by the constitution.
Although it would most likely be futile for government to regulate uncivil speech, society has the choice to combat these ignorant and harmful statements. Citizens can actively stand against uncivil speech and advocate the truth (or at least their version of it). Morals may be defended this way without the suppression of voices, no matter how insensitive or ridiculous they may be. Government and local powers should however reserve the authority to investigate any discourse which they suspect to be a source of legitimate danger. Though uncivil discourse may be harmful to society, it is the role of the people not the government to regulate its presence.


 

Manuel Alfaro Uncivil Discourse

Manuel Alfaro
Professor Kubel
Soc 3
1 May 2017
Uncivil discourse has the capacity to become harmful, but there's two sides to this. It has the capacity to influence actions from an individual level to a more social level. I'll be taking the side on ways it can inspire non-harmful actions.
In the article, Colin Kaepernick is a Patriot. And Your Respectful Disagreement Makes You One Too, by John Riofrio a professor at College of William and Mary discusses how former NFL quarterback Colin Kaepernick's way of protesting (kneeling during the national anthem) was in a respectful manner, something that no matter what side you are on, conservative or liberal, should understand. The author finds Kaepernick's protest to stand up for two things the United States has long stood for and that is freedom and equality, that his protest is an effort to stand up and protect his freedom and raise awareness of racism and discrimination against Blacks. He makes the argument that politicians are have plenty of wealth that blinds them to the daily realities Americans face especially minorities, something that he truthfully thinks that people don't have a sense to what being a minority is like. That we live in socially segregated society and where we live in communities where the majority of people are copies of one another and when it comes to minorities they have to deal with being treated differently by schools, police, the justice system and banks. But society doesn't see this, they don't see what Latinos, African Americans, Asian Americans, and Native Americans go through with poverty and forgotten rural corners. What Kaepernick is protesting it's real, bringing attention to the fact that United States, the land of the free and equal rights, are still treating people of color differently in a negative way. According to the author Kaepernick has protested the correct way, he didn't make a press announcement, didn't make noise and did it without violence all he did was respectfully kneeled during the national anthem, something that is a sign of respect such as praying or showing respect to someone who gets hurt during a game.
Could these actions by Colin Kapernick cause uncivil discourse, therefore encouraging minorities to revolt and rebel against law enforcement and Whites? It is a possibility, it could also be considered the complete opposite, encouraging peaceful acts of protest. It is not the act of kneeling down during the national anthem that I agree with, but rather with the idea of doing so in a non-violent way.














Works Cited

Matthew Bevers, Uncivil Discourse, Berkeley Riots


Matthew Bevers
5/3/17
Soc 111
Uncivil Discourse
Uncivil discourse is a problem in this country, but it's not quite the problem that people think it is. As far as I understand, the definition of civil discourse is that topics are discussed in an uncivilized manner. Uncivil discourse to me, is not the discussion of controversial topics. Even if language is used that some people don't find appropriate, it shouldn't be seen as uncivil discourse. Nothing should be done about uncivil discourse except to arrest people using violent means or breaking laws to express their opinion.  Uncivil discourse is more problematic whenever people use violent means to disagree with someone such as the recent "protests" at UC Berkeley. The word protest is used lightly because the events at Berkeley more resemble riots than protests. Antifas are running around the streets with hoods and masks so that they can cowardly hide their faces while attacking people and destroying property. Right-wing supporters are decked out in full battle gear while wearing "Make America Great Again" paraphernalia. UC Berkeley, once the shining example of free speech, was turned into a violent battlefield with young immature idiots making a mockery of free speech. What caused the riots was first the planned speech of Milo Yiannopoulos, a former Breitbart editor and controversial conservative figurehead. People threatened his life and started tearing apart the surrounding area in protest of his speech. A similar situation occurred whenever Ann Coulter, another conservative speaker, was planned to speak. Obviously we can see that the problem occurs whenever conservative speakers come to campus. This uncivil discourse that targets conservatives is pathetic and only exists because of the liberal snowflakes of Berkeley that cannot handle a different opinion besides their own.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/grade-point/wp/2017/04/26/milos-appearance-at-berkeley-led-to-riots-he-vows-to-return-this-fall-for-a-week-long-free-speech-event/?utm_term=.847a389f2e50

Codie McKeighen, Hate Speech

Codie McKeighen
Sociology 111
3 May 2017
Hate Speech
Going solely with the definition of hate speech, I would say that it is harmful especially in the wrong audience. I think it is easy to be disgruntled by another person's opinion and we, as humankind, have a hard time not being right or having the last say. We are all going to have an opinion, but we need to learn how to cope and understand how to either keep those opinions to ourselves or how to appreciate another person's differing opinion.
There is however, a fine line between what is okay and what is not okay. It is okay to have an opinion and share that opinion if you feel necessary – after all its one of our rights, by law. It is not okay to use your opinion to spew death threats or as a terrorist act. As a society, we need to learn how to filter, be it personally and through the media. Our media seems to find the most horrifying and worst things to share, very rarely is there something positive going on in the news.
In an article titled "The Freedom to Ignore Hate Speech", published in the Opinion section of the San Francisco Chronicle, Madeleine Change discusses the differing sides on UC Berkeley's campus. Berkeley, known for its student activists supports students of both political views and struggles while its student's try to prepare for finals, along with fighting for their right to free speech. The conflict originated after Berkeley College Republicans invited a woman by the name of Ann Coulter – a conservative – to speak on campus. Rather than prepping for finals and the upcoming school year, admins became apprehensive about the possibility of a protest. The suggestion was to move the speech to the next week when most of the students would not be on campus and prepping for finals during their "dead week". In the end, the school was sued for encroaching on the student's First Amendment rights.
Therefore, I feel as though the problem is not necessarily the hate speech – because everyone is entitled to his or her opinion – but how we react. We can only control how our actions and ourselves. In regards to the article, what the school did to prevent a riot was a smart move on their part but at the same time it limited the group with whom they reached and how their spread their campaign. There is no solution to hate speech, we solely need to control how we react and maybe try to consider others. That is the only change we have complete control over – the change within ourselves.

mw3:15-445soc 111 GENEVIEVE ALEMAN

UNCIVIL DISCORSE
Genevieve Aleman
MW 3:30-4:45p.m
SOC 111

            Uncivil discourse has always been and will probably always be a topic of controversy. Blunt rude comments, offend people, and offended people will cause quite a bit of chaos.
            Now, obviously there are instances where it is crystal clear when speech should be punished or not, for example, a co-worker telling an employee "I really want to rape you right now" should absolutely be punished. I would argue that, speech should be punished when it is leading directly to physical harm. For example, a member of a group like the "kkk" saying "I want to hang an African American" should be punished or restricted in some form. Why? Well because an individual that has a high probability of actually hurting an African American as well as a history of doing so is making this statement.
            Limiting free speech, in my opinion, is to limit democracy and in the process of this, our reputation of being the "free country" is tarnished. Publically punishing somebody for uncivil discourse sets an example for others that says speaking in opposition, (or thinking in opposition) to a political leader will result in undesired consequences. Too keep a free country and to keep democracy FREE speech and instances of uncivil disclosure are vital. You can not take passion and impulse out of a human without taking their free will. I agree that it (it being uncivil discourse) is not the most tasteful way to express your opinion, but in the end it's your opinion and it is a package deal with freedom.
            I think situations such as Ward Churchill and our very own Fresno State professor demonstrate suppression of free speech. This is not the way to handle uncivil discourse. I think the punishment of our Fresno State professor as well as Churchill, results in professors down playing, sugar coating, or even hiding their opinions which ultimately prevents students from being exposed to controversial topics that push them to broaden their perspectives. Opening your mind is a major importance of college.  This punishment also sends the message to students and the public that if you don't conform to what's expected you will be shoved out. I agree his words were harsh and I understand why some people feel as though his words were seen as very "inappropriate" to some. But, to me personally, its absolutely absurd to tell a grown adult "no you cant say that", "don't feel that" because its not ok to others. You have the right to your thoughts; they are, after all, YOUR thoughts.
            Also I have to say that anybody with a capacity to understand the concepts of sarcasm and exaggeration would also understand that this professor was not about to literally raise money to hang Trump. The probability of him actually hanging trump is nonexistent. I also must say that this professor in no way should be held accountable for the Fresno shooting of four men. I think that is a ridiculous stretch.
            Uncivil discourse can be harmful in the sense that it angers people but it is far more dangerous to punish all instances of uncivil discourse. Citizens must be allowed to fully express their opinions, especially regarding politics. If opinions and speech are restricted so will the power of the people.

Katherine Morales - Uncivil Discourse

                        Uncivil discourse is ubiquitous in our nation and particularly rampant on the internet. Many of us hide behind our keyboards and let our feelings known, no matter how crass they may be. Our country is split into many different factions: raider fans/49er fans, diet coke drinkers/regular coke drinkers etc.. Two factions, however, Democrats and Republicans are the most prominent. Especially in recent years, the interactions between these two factions have become nothing short of a farce. I watch my government at work and I am ashamed. They take money in exchange for governmental influence. They strip healthcare from millions for the sake of tax cuts. They change district lines so they'll be reelected into a seat they do not deserve. They argue, they fight and they look foolish. If the people that constitute my government cannot act civilly, how will their people act civilly? We too argue, fight and think less of those around us.  In my opinion, uncivil discourse keeps us from growing. We are so busy fighting an illusory fight, democrat vs republican, that we cannot see passed our "opponent" and hold our government accountable for its actions. This is harmful to our country.

            For example, a couple of weeks ago a riot ensued in Berkeley, California. An anti-trump rally ran into a pro-trump rally and chaos ensued. People made makeshift weapons out of sticks with the intent to harm one another. I was disappointed when I read the news that morning. What was accomplished? Nothing was accomplished. Thirteen people were arrested and many more were injured. This like this do not have to happen.

            If we can only not participate in uncivil discourse, we can make real change. We can put people into office that will actually represent our wishes. If we don't have label "Democrat" or "Republican" we can actually look at an issue and use our own judgment, not a judgment that has been predetermined by us. I think we need to look past party lines in order to make change. We cannot afford for our country to be "us" vs "them" anymore, for there is too much suffering in the world to be distracted.

 

http://www.cbsnews.com/news/protesters-arrested-as-pro-trump-and-anti-trump-rallies-clash-in-berkeley/