A Citizen's Responsibility to Combat Uncivil Discourse
Uncivil discourse decreases the quality of rhetoric in professional, academic and social communication. It is a blemish to logic and draws attention away from legitimate arguments. However, due to the broad and nearly undefinable nature of the term "uncivil discourse", it would be difficult (if not impossible) to restrict these statements altogether.
Incidents of uncivil discourse occur daily and are not out of place in modern society. However, occurrences of uncivil discourse seemed to run rampant during the 2016 Presidential elections. There were rash words from both sides, straddling the line between argument and insult. These statements however did not just apply from one party to the opposing party. They often occurred within parties. An example of this is displayed by President Donald Trump's statement about Republican presidential candidate Ben Carson.
Trump used Carson's own description of his past bouts of temper as a young man against him. He hinted that his "pathological" temper was something that could not be cured. However, the part of the statement that began to be uncivil was when Trump compared Carson's fault to "a child molester." He asserted that there was essentially no cure except a cure that he said he did not want to mention. This could be considered uncivil discourse as it hinted that Carson was at the very least, comparable to a child molester.
This statement had nothing to do with the issue at hand. Rather, it was a direct attack on Carson's character, one that held no factual pretense. Essentially, Trump connected the label of child molester to his competitor's name in the minds of the public. He made Carson out to be "pathologically diseased" simply because the man admitted to a weakness of his past ways. This statement had nothing to do with Carson's policies. It only aimed to label him as an unqualified presidential candidate.
This qualifies as uncivil discourse because it is a brash and unfortified statement. However, politicians, government officials and citizens make such statements on a day to day basis. To identify which statements deserve censorship would be a monumental task. In order to accomplish this, the term "civil discourse" would first have to be defined. People would have to answer questions such as "If no violence is hinted at, is it still uncivil?" and "Do we censor every civilian post or just those that imply racist, ignorant or absurd assertions?" Here the freedom of speech and uncivil discourse meet face to face. While, uncivil discourse is harmful, it can not combat the power of free speech granted to citizens by the constitution.
Although it would most likely be futile for government to regulate uncivil speech, society has the choice to combat these ignorant and harmful statements. Citizens can actively stand against uncivil speech and advocate the truth (or at least their version of it). Morals may be defended this way without the suppression of voices, no matter how insensitive or ridiculous they may be. Government and local powers should however reserve the authority to investigate any discourse which they suspect to be a source of legitimate danger. Though uncivil discourse may be harmful to society, it is the role of the people not the government to regulate its presence.
No comments:
Post a Comment