Who's the racist here? Loving compassionate Progressive communist. I wonder if Fresno State would invite her to speak. Oh no they would have to go to their safe space. But she has tenure. A get out of jail card. It's sickening.
Thursday, April 19, 2018
Who is the racist? What is free speech?
Who's the racist here? Loving compassionate Progressive communist. I wonder if Fresno State would invite her to speak. Oh no they would have to go to their safe space. But she has tenure. A get out of jail card. It's sickening.
Friday, December 1, 2017
Uncivil discourse: Does it matter?
This was originally published in April of 2017, but was bumped.
"You have the right to free speech as long as you're not dumb enough to actually try it."- Know Your Rights by The Clash
Uncivil discourse has become a popular problem.
(click to enlarge)
How does uncivil discourse (polemics, invective, hate speech) influence actual behavior?
April 2017 was a rough month for Fresno -- Fresno State was in the national news for the professor that tweeted death threats against Trump, and Fresno was in the news for a mass-murderer that targeted four white males. This isn't quite as embarrassing as having one of our students get caught having sex with a sheep on campus, because he was stressed from finals, but its right up there.
The above cartoon was printed in the student newspaper. Yea, we made headlines that time. You can read more and catch a wonderful headline here.
The Professor, the gunman and other' bad hombres'.
I've heard a few people suggest the professor's tweets and the mass murderer are related, and ask the question: Did the gunman do the work advocated by the professor?
The Fresno State professor's statements on Twitter that Trump should be hanged and Trump and other politicians should be assassinated were beyond the pale and I'm glad he's been fired from our university. Regardless of free speech rights and the need for us to be protected so we can teach controversial stances on subjects (and controversial subjects), advocacy of murder and violence should not be tolerated -- especially by someone that is supposed to be an intellectual leader of our community. Of course, there are sometimes when advocacy of killing and violence is acceptable, such as support for war, death penalty and punishment for treason, as just a few examples. That does confuse the issue a bit, doesn't it?
If the professor had said this in the course of a class, and given reasons for the advocating the killing, such as treason, and explained what the treasonous behavior was, I would say that is protected speech and worthy of intellectual debate. But the faculty wasn't in class and there was no charge of treason and no intellectual reasoning to support the violent statement -- the closest thing to that was that Trump's policies were bad for America and ruining our democracy. Advocating violence for political purposes (or with political justification) is unacceptable and the basic definition of terrorism. But again we are ignoring all sorts of people that are employed to kill for political purposes (or with political justifications) such as soldiers, police, or prison guards who pull the lever for capital punishment.
I remember many people saying that Hillary and Barack Obama should be hung for treason. The following image was among the many that were spread on social media,
And this uncivil discourse was not just among outsiders; a Republican candidate for the Florida House of Representatives repeated the charge on Twitter,
Making such a charge, and giving the reasoning behind it, I think would be legally acceptable, but the Fresno State professor didn't do that: Just saying people should be hung and asking for donations for committing such murder as did this professor, all because of policy differences or to assuage some general harm to society is outrageous and worthy of a non-tenured professor losing his job. A tenured professor, I think, would be punished but not fired. Tenure gives you some protection so a firing for your detested speech would be much harder to do. Remember Ward Churchill?
ward churchill
Professor of ethnic studies at University of Colorado, Boulder, and leader of the American Indian Movement, Ward Churchill said, the day after 9/11, that the attack was our own fault because of our bombing of little babies overseas, that the World Trade Center was a legitimate military target because the military is only used when we have world trade interests, and that the people working in the World Trade Center were complicit. He called them "Little Eichmans" to compare them to the Nazi Adolph Eichman who was convicted for crimes against humanity and hanged, even though he didn't hate Jews and was just doing his job as a bureaucrat who ran the trains that took people to the concentration camps. Churchill's statement was widely publicized by the now-unemployed Bill O-Reilly, which caused a national controversy for Churchill's university. Churchill had tenure and was able to keep his job through years of witch hunt investigations and trials, but eventually he succumbed to the pressure and was fired. He tried to take his case to the U.S Supreme Court, but they refused to hear his case.
OK, back to the Fresno case:. Are the Fresno killer and the Fresno professor related? Why did the killer decide to kill now as opposed to some other time? Could the statements advocating violence by the professor have served as some sort of short-term motivation?
How hate speech is related to actual violent actions is hard to know. Often there is not any direct connection, but an indirect connection may still occur, even if people don't acknowledge it.
The killing of 4 whites in Fresno gained national attention, I think, largely because the victims were white. It has also been suggested that the victims were chosen at random, which belies the truth that the victims were chosen because they were white males.
This is another example of how whiteness (and to a lesser extent gender) is invisible in this country -- when whites are targeted it is commonly but wrongly described as totally random. Similarly when males are always the perpetrators (E.g., school shootings) gender is never even mentioned. Many scholars have written extensively on the topic of invisibility for white males, and most describe it as an unearned privilege. Usually they don't talk about privilege in relation to (how we think about) crime and violence, but that relationship is becoming clearer.
Despite the widespread reports that the perpetrator was a terrorist, the Fresno police have repeatedly, and from the very beginning, said this was a hate crime against whites and NOT terrorism, even though the person had a Muslim-sounding name and cried out in Arabic when arrested. Actually we are learning that he wasn't Muslim but was polytheistic. Also, if the gunman had been doing the work of the professor, he would have gone after politicians and Trump, not white males.
Still, I also wonder if there is some relationship between the gunman and the violent rhetoric of the professor, in the same way I wonder if there is a relationship between the right-wing BS spouted by Trump/allies and the rise of violent right-wing militia groups. The difference is that there is no explicit relationship between the professor and the killer, and many members of these militia groups repeatedly and specifically say they are given hope by the rise of Trump. On the opposite side of the political spectrum there are examples of killers who say they were motivated by support for the black lives matter rhetoric. During the 1960's and 1970's members of the American Indian Movement, Black Panthers, Young Lords, and Weathermen are just a few examples of the "liberal" "activist" groups that used violence for political ends. I'm not sure of an Asian focused group, but these groups courted young liberals from all the other major race/ethnic groups -- American Indians, Blacks, Latinos, and Whites. They gained members, motivation, and justification from violent or revolutionary rhetoric. Some members of these groups took part in violent political actions, and some have been charged with murdering police. Many of them have a long list of members murdered by government or political enemies, and members jailed as political prisoners.
cointelpro The counter-intelligence program (cointelpro) part starts at 39 minutes and 20 seconds.
The government created a counter-intelligence program that used the FBI to send in undercover agents to infiltrate these ethnic movements, and used propaganda to instigate inter-movement discord and violence. They also used disinformation campaigns in the national media, and even instigated violence that ended in deaths among the activists, as well as government agents.
And there are other cases where the connection between uncivil discourse and violent behavior have been documented, such as during the November 2016 election, the wacko that believed the fake news story that Hillary Clinton was organizing a satanic child sex ring out of the back of a pizza parlor, and traveled hundreds of miles to the pizza shop with an automatic rifle to stop the crime.
Dylan Roof -- the convicted mass murderer who killed parishioners in a South Carolina Black church said his main motivation was what he had learned from propaganda websites about how Blacks were killing and raping Whites so much that it was a genocide. He felt he was compelled to stop it.
Causes
The violent rhetoric comes from dehumanization of adversaries, which is the same kind of propaganda that we are constantly fed by the national media during and before war.
Slavery was justified for decades by prejudiced beliefs about Black and Native inferiority.
Sociologists teach that prejudice is an outcome and justification for inequality.
Solutions
If we want to stop prejudice, we need to look at the distribution of resources in society. Addressing inequality won't stop uncivil discourse, but likely it will make uncivil discourse less likely. There is a lot of evidence that it is not the lack of money or poverty that causes the most common social problems in a U.S. state or society, but rather it is those states or countries that have the most inequitable distribution of resources that suffer the most social problems. I would guess that uncivil discourse could be added, alongside crime, obesity, smoking, and other social problems as an unintended consequence of inequality.
Another simple solution is censorship. We could censor uncivil discourse, and we could outlaw all public display of bias. This sounds outrageous to us, but probably wouldn't to the French who place all sorts of restrictions on the right to speak about or even wear religious symbols or clothing in public.
I hope the loss of free speech rights is not the end result of our misuse of our freedoms.
The U.S. Supreme Court has even upheld the rights of the KKK to burn a cross on their own land and even to hold a birthday party for Hitler in public spaces within Jewish neighborhoods.
Despite the constitutional protections, free speech is under assault by uncivil discourse. Whether hate speech is free speech is at the cornerstone of this debate.
On one hand, we should not tolerate speech that promotes hate.
On the other hand, if we only allow speech that someone doesn't define as hate, then nobody will have any free speech rights.
This poses a dilemma -- whose speech -- or what speech -- is protected? Should we censor some speech? Whose -- or what -- speech should be censored? If we decide to ban speech that poses a real threat to some individual or group of people, then how do we define "threat" and who gets to decide if some speech is a threat?
Restricting free speech -- to some extent -- has to be part of the solution. I would hope that it would be a small part of the solution rather than a large part of the solution.
How would you resolve this free speech dilemma? How could that solution be put into place?
Another solution is violence. This horrible solution is becoming popular.
Recently there have been violent events on college campuses in reaction to conservative speakers who say they are exercising their rights to free speech. Earlier this year in Berkeley there were violent protests in reaction to a planned campus speech by an offensive writer for Breitbart News. More recently, Berkeley cancelled a speech by Ann Coulter because of concerns over her safety, and even more recently a pro-Trump rally was disrupted by anti-Trump protesters who used violence to break up the pro-Trump rally.. There seems to be a growing belief that conservatives that advocate inequality and white hetero male privilege should be defined as hate speech, and that hate speech not only should be censored but also should be met with violence.
I certainly do not agree with the violent solution advocated by some college students who suggest violence is warranted to stop the hate speech,
Only in a perverse world does violence (and terrorism?) become justified as a solution to hate speech. Obviously violence is not a valid solution to hate speech.
However, that there are so many people advocating this solution shows us the power of the connection between physical violence and hate speech.
Another simple example is to look at the hate crime statistics, which by definition represent the combination of hateful speech and violent crimes.
https://www.fbi.gov/news/stories/2015-hate-crime-statistics-released
Violence between citizens should not be seen as part of uncivil discourse, but censorship and overcoming inequality are two viable solutions. Of course, we might teach people to avoid prejudice but that does not target prejudice at its root cause. Attacking inequality may be especially effective way to reduce both uncivil discourse and violence
Regardless of the solution, I can say with certainty that too often, uncivil discourse shapes (or justifies) violent behavior. Of course the violent behavior must be condemned, but too often we ignore the related uncivil discourse.
Trump and Science
All of the above examples are related to uncivil discourse, and Trump has perhaps been one of the worst perpetrators among mainstream politicians. There are so many different kinds of violent, inaccurate, sexist, homophobic, and prejudiced messages from Trump it is hard to document them all. While most are obviously propaganda, some lies are harder to dissect as they are presented as "facts", such as this,
Documenting all the cases of Trump's uncivil discourse would be interesting, and in fact some intellectuals have already analyzed it and produced some charts comparing Trump to others. Another interesting tool analyzes how we reacted to the election on twitter: https://www.pri.org/ stories/2016-04-29/just-how- uncivil-election-2016-mits- media-lab-has-some-charts-you- should-see
It is interesting to note that while Trump's supporters have a considerably higher rate of uncivil discourse, for at least a portion of the election season, the differences between Trump and the Democratic Party rivals was not a very large difference. There doesn't seem to be a massive partisan divide -- uncivil discourse is used by both republican and democratic supporters.
Lets remember some basic principles of science. The rise of Trump and the rise of hate crimes against Muslims and the rise of white supremacist groups does not mean that Trump's rhetoric was the cause. Correlation does not mean causation. Because Trump's uncivil discourse was not a singular cause of the rise of these groups, does not mean that Trump's uncivil discourse was not one of several causes of the rise of these violent right wing groups. The same can be said for the uncivil discourse in general -- it is not likely ever the singular cause of violent behavior, but, as I've argued in this essay, it certainly could be one of several important causes.
Conclusion
Anyone that thinks that uncivil discourse doesn't matter needs to look at these cases described above and rethink their position. Sometimes the connections between the violence and rhetoric is explicit and sometimes it is not, but I for one don't hesitate to condemn uncivil discourse and acknowledge that it has intended and unintended consequences.
Please leave your educated thoughts about the topic of uncivil discourse below.
-Tim Kubal
Wednesday, October 4, 2017
Taking a knee, inter-ethnic distrust, and the culture war
Regardless of the investigation about Russia, Trump is no fool. He knows how to stoke the culture war for his own benefit.
However, wading into the culture war may do more harm to Trump than he thinks. Likely if we talked a lot more about his failures he would work harder to overcome these failures. If we don't acknowledge the failures, perhaps he will work less hard to overcome them. If you don’t support Trump’s policies, perhaps you should actually support these forays into the culture wars, at least until the next election.
Sunday, October 1, 2017
Re: uncivil discourse and the Trump Phenomenon
I don't like to see any restrictions on speech, I shudder when I see protests at Berkeley. I note the far left has also condemned such actions, both Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren condemned the protests. Warren in effect said let her speak, a few people will show up and she will largely be ignored.
As one writer in your blog said, Trump is using race and patriotism for political purposes.
I don't buy trump is a racist, he above all is fixated on winning, defined as making money, receiving praise, being labeled a winner. I know he has a history in Real Estate of discrimination against blacks. I suggest that was a marketing move, he could sell more condos for more money if no blacks were invited, at least he thought so. his comments against hispanics, muslims blacks all for the benefit of praise and adoration by the base. I think his health care plan was in the tank, not going to pass and he comes out with this patriotic stuff about the NFL players. Kopernick taking the knee was largely old news, in a few weeks completely forgotten. he resurrected it knowing it would inflame the right and deflect criticism from his failing efforts to repeal obamacare. I think he has no principals conservative or liberal, racists or progressive. he does and says whatever he needs to stoke his ego.I watched the Vietnam doc. last night and saw Spiro Agnew spouted off about how the anti-war protestors were not only unpatriotic, putting our soldiers at risk but dangerous. they all want to destroy our country. in response the black student president of the Northwestern University explained she and her followers condemned violence, and were just wanting a civil discussionand pointed out that Agnew was trying to frighten the public and thereby divide us in his attempt to promote the war. I called mom in and played it again. it all sounded so familiar.
Thursday, September 28, 2017
Reaction to Blog
Fwd: white christians v. black christians and the protests
I thought I would compare it to one national survey, the General Social Survey. I did a few quick tables looking only at people that identified as Christian (Protestant, Catholic, or other Christian were the answer choices), then examining how Blacks and Whites within these Christian groups responded differently to questions about protest. While I think the author may be right, the evidence in this national random poll suggests that Black Christians are more likely to support protest in most cases, but that the difference is small and not statistically significant.
Date: Thu, Sep 28, 2017 at 1:36 PM
Subject: white christians v. black christians and the protests
To: mkubal@indylaw.net, tkubal@csufresno.edu
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/
uncivil discourse and the Trump Phenomenon
jdkubal@aol.com
Monday, September 11, 2017
participation assignent
Wednesday, May 10, 2017
Isabel Gonzalez , Uncivil Discourse
Gonzalez, Isabel
5/10/17
Sociology 3
Uncivil Discourse
Uncivil discourse is such a major issue dealt with in today's society with it becoming much more recurrent after Trump was elected president. People have found it okay to make threats or become violent with people just because their race, gender, or sexuality. Uncivil discourse is very harmful and has led to people being discriminated, bullied, and other violent acts which needs to be stopped.
The article, "Racial Discrimination In The Woodlands Concerns Residents Board", by Kelly Schafler, is a current example that exemplified how civil disclosure has grown after the election of Trump. Kelly Schafler discusses how she had been living in the Woodland community for years with the community becoming more diverse and being open to the different cultures living there. However, she then begins to discuss after Trump was elected community members begun to discriminate against Latinos. It first began with people mumbling rude comments whenever her or her family spoke Spanish and eventually led to her children being bullied and discriminated in school. It has gotten too out of hand that Kelly has decided to move from Woodlands for the safety of her family.
The only solution that could be put in place is for the President who has the power and is the bases of why uncivil disobedience has become so recurrent. Trump must act or change the way he exemplifies his message as a president. Right now, he is giving off the message that discrimination is okay and he needs to confront hoping that would cause discrimination to die down. We must come together as a society and fight for the right to express our right and stop this violence. We must fight for love and peace instead of violence.
Article:http://www.chron.com/neighborhood/woodlands/news/article/Racial-discrimination-in-The-Woodlands-concerns-11039162.phpMatthew Martinez Uncivil Discourse
Matt Martinez
Uncivil Discourse
Sociology 3
Uncivil Discourse
Uncivil discourse has become a growing issue within the United States, and I certainly believe that it is an extremely harmful one. In recent days it seems as if people with differing opinions seem to be arguing less and less about how they feel about their given opinions, and instead look to attack the other person directly instead of attacking the argument they are making. American people have become far too closed-minded to any new beliefs or opinions that differ from their own, and this polarization of opinions have led to extreme levels of uncivil discourse within our country. In the world of politics, the rise of Donald Trump to President of the United States has led to increased separation of the political parties and ideologies, and each side seems more determined to destroy the other instead of focusing on fixing America. The two parties are focused on fighting dirty, and this uncivil discourse has resulted in nothing but hatred and gridlock between the two main parties and their supporters. To each party, any person of the other party must be attacked and destroyed, instead of that party's policies or ideas.
Uncivil discourse is extremely harmful, as it leads to growing contempt and destroys any possibility of thoughtful debate and spreading of ideas. As divisions within our country seem to be growing, I fear that very little can be done to stop the growth of uncivil discourse. Hatred seems to be running at an all time high in America, and this has manifested itself in much more extreme civil discourse than we have seen in recent times. The only solution to civil discourse, however, would be love, and realizing that besides some minor differences in opinion, we are all the same on the inside. America needs to look to shine through our disagreements, and our people need to learn that love is more powerful than hate.
One important thing that we must keep in mind as well, is that differing opinions on certain issues don't always stem out of hatred. All too often these days, people have become far too quick to condemn someone with an opinion different from their own as hateful, which isn't usually the case. When this happens, free speech becomes threatened, because those who have opinions to share are too quickly shut down.
As many of my classmates have chosen to do, as well as my professor, I have decided to write about the Milo Yiannopoulos event being shut down by violent protesters who disagreed with his messages. When right-wing speaker Yiannopoulos was scheduled to appear to speak at UC Berkeley several months ago, violent protesters attacked and caused an estimated $100,000 damage to the campus and its surroundings. The speech had to be cancelled, but Yiannopoulos and his team were not hurt. I find these events disturbing, because they seem to be the perfect example of how uncivil discourse may be leading to restrictions on free speech. Where Yiannopoulos wished to speak peacefully, he was not allowed, due to some people having differing opinions from his, and deciding to act on those opinions in a violent manner.
http://www.cnn.com/2017/02/01/us/milo-yiannopoulos-berkeley/index.html
Arix Pokorny Hate speech or Free Speech
Uncivil Discourse shouldn't go unnoticed in our world but at the same time it shouldn't be blown out of proportion and over hyped like it does happen sometimes. To me hate speech seems to be the biggest problem due to the wide variety of problems that fall into what is considered hate speech. Like you said on the blog what is considered free speech and what is considered hate speech as well as what is protected or unprotected.
The article I chose was about protesting Milo at Berkley where there was at first a peaceful protest of the speaker but then violent protesters showed up requiring milo to be evacuated as well as 100,000 dollar's worth of damage according to CNN. The reason that I choose this world event is because it gives me a chance to explain what I believe is free speech and what is hate speech. Now when it comes to Milo he takes a very unorthodox approach to how he gets his point across when it comes to his speeches across all the campuses that he visited. Although he has a different way of speech what he does is still protected under free speech even if it is offensive to some people, but other people that fall under the same category may not find it offensive. The reason I bring that up is that when it comes to deciding what is free speech and what is hate speech feeling should be thrown out of the conversation because some people are more sensitive to topics than others. An example for that is when a kid hops on social media and says I wish my parents would die, although they may not meahing that n it literally and might be upset of a recent punishment. Now that is their free speech it's not meant to be taken seriously, but what about a kid that may be friends with them that has lost their parents and misses them. Although it is upsetting to the kid it wasn't hate speech directed at him to make him upset him for not having parents. I said all that for the purpose that what Milo says may offend or upset some people's feelings but it is not hate speech because it upset you.
Another thing that I don't feel should be considered when it comes to hate speech is politics respectively. The reason I feel that way is when it comes to politics whether you lean to the left or the right if someone from the opposite side says something you don't agree with shouldn't be considered hate speech, which is another reason I chose Milo at Berkeley was because people have the freedom to protest peacefully if they like, but when people consider it to be hate speech because he gives speeches to people that do want to hear what he has to say and are more conservative, then become violent that isn't okay. The reason I believe that Milo should have been allowed on campuses is because conservative students should be able to hear out other conservative speakers, if liberal students can hear liberal speakers without any repercussion or fear it may be shut downs.
A solution that I think there is a chance to help with that speech and free speech is being open minded. I know it is a stretch for more people to be open minded but if people where more open minded then there would be less people that find it to be hate speech if they hear out why someone thinks the way they do. Even if you don't agree with what they must say but if you end up hearing out what others have to say on the topic that you don't agree with you may be able to understand the persons thought process and therefore less offended or less likely to call it hate speech. Although that wouldn't be the way it would work for everything because racism no matter how hard someone tried to explain their thought process wouldn't be acceptable.
End the end I believe that hate speech is an issue in the world that the media blows out of proportion in some cases. Another thing that I believe in is that there is a difference between hate speech and freedom of speech that weighs in on a lot. To go along with the free speech and hate speech A solution to that is people being open minded enough to understand the thought process behind the thought could help reduce violent actions taken in response to what someone had to say.
Article: http://www.cnn.com/2017/02/01/us/milo-yiannopoulos-berkeley/index.html
















