Sunday, May 7, 2017

Aisha Dhesi, Uncivil Discourse involving Sikhs

Aisha Dhesi

T Kubal

Soc 3

8 May 2017

Uncivil Discourse

Uncivil discourse has been a controversy for a while. It can be identified as hate speech. I think uncivil discourse should be censored. Our system is wrong if it allows the KKK to hold birthday parties for Hitler in Jewish neighborhoods. This is disrespectful to those who have first handedly witnessed the Holocaust and makes it seem as if the genocide is considered a joke. Speech that generates hate and targets a specific group of people should not be tolerated.

The First Amendment protects everyone's right for freedom of speech. Insulting comments regarding one's religion, sexual orientation, or ethnicity is allowed as long as it does not incorporate threats or evoke violence. Since Trump has been president, there have been several instances in the news that show that people think it is okay to openly be racist and practice uncivil discourse. This is morally wrong because why would one say something rude to someone else when they are not causing harm to anyone?

On March 6, 2017 CNN did a news report on hate speech regarding the Sikh community. It was reported that a man came up to a Sikh gentlemen's driveway and told him to "Go back to his country." This is something that is quite frequently heard for those who are non white and it hurts when people stereotype you as an immigrant because you are someone of color. Technically, this is a uncivil discourse and is protected right under the First Amendment of the Constitution. However, then the man pulled out a gun during the conversation and shot the Sikh. This is considered a hate crime and is not protected under the Constitution because it involved violence. Now the question is, did the uncivil discourse evoke the hate crime? Uncivil discourse is harmful because it can cause people to act irrational and think that it is okay to say anything without having a filter. This is rude and shows that hate speech can fuel hate related crimes, which is why uncivil discourse should be censored. People should not have to worry about being bullied and be told to deal with it. Furthermore, society should teach bullies not to attack individuals both verbally and physically.

http://www.cnn.com/2017/03/05/us/washington-sikh-shooting/

Toni Ortiz

Sociology 3

     The topic of uncivil discourse leaves people wondering if it is harmful or completely harmless and just a matter of free speech. Some may not realize the difference between uncivil discourse, otherwise known as threats, and free speech. Just because you have the freedom to say anything, it doesn't give you the right to do so in a way that can have serious consequences. In this case there is a right and wrong to humanity. It is common sense to know that if one makes a threatening statement, someone else is likely to take it very seriously and there may be harmful consequences. The words themselves don't seem harmful until someone takes it way out of context and believes that what the person says is actually true. Who knows? That person who made the threat may be serious about it. This is why it is important to recognize uncivil discourse.

     In a Fresno Bee article posted recently, a 15-year-old boy was threatening to shoot up his school, Mt. Whitney High. Although officers say that he did not own a weapon nor did he have access to one, the boy was arrested anyway and then taken to a juvenile detention. This proves how seriously threats are being taken. The boy was probably not going to do it, but the fact that he brought it up arose suspicion. No one is willing to take any chances to the consequences that may have progressed by his uncivil statement. Especially since this took place in a school setting, it is important that they keep the students safe from any harm. A threat is just the first step towards a criminal act.

     It shouldn't be questioned why uncivil discourse would be in any way safe and just a matter of free speech. Threats can be harmful. In the example I stated earlier about the boy threatening to shoot up the school, this not only made the boy in suspicion of being a criminal, but there could have been other consequences that may have involved the matter of his own life. There are many different ways to look at the situation, but none of them seems to be a positive outcome. I believe uncivil discourse is harmful and it should be taken seriously throughout the world. Uncivil discourse shouldn't be treated equally as freedom of speech.

http://www.fresnobee.com/news/local/education/article148740299.html 

Megan Clays Uncivil Discourse

Megan Clays

Kubal

Sociology 3

5/7/2017

                                                     How Harmful Uncivil Discourse Is

           Uncivil discourse has been the cause of many hate filled stories we hear about in the news. It is a hard topic to provide a solution for because most of the solutions revolve around censoring people and the media—which we are unable to do because our country allows people to exercise their right of freedom of speech. Recent events such as the mass murder committed by Dylann Roof and the UC Berkeley riots show how harmful uncivil discourse actually is.

            A main example of someone who uses uncivil discourse would be Milo Yiannoppoulos, who is known for letting his opinions on gender, feminism, and race, be known. Due to his uncivility Milo's speech was canceled on Berkeley's campus after protesters began defacing the campus by throwing bricks, setting off fireworks, hitting windows, and setting things on fire. Milo claims that Berkeley was trying to censor him by cancelling his speech instead of it being cancelled for his and the students on campus safety.

            Milo's extreme way of expressing himself put a lot of people in danger because of the Berkeley riots. All he did was practice his right of freedom of speech but it led to a very dangerous event. Although Milo says very offensive things he technically isn't committing a crime like the some of the violent protesters did while destroying parts of Berkeley's campus. That's where it's hard to make a decision—does Milo get punished because he exercised the first amendment or does he go free even though he was the reason the dangerous protest started in the first place?

            I don't know how the Berkeley riots can be fixed—I think there's power in ignoring people you don't agree with rather than becoming violent.  Uncivil discourse will never go away. If people were to be censored or have their freedom of speech revoked we'd have even more problems to deal with. Overall, uncivil discourse is very harmful because we can't really censor people and we can't stop people from disagreeing but we can try to minimize the violence as much as possible.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Bibliography

1.      https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/grade-point/wp/2017/02/01/berkeley-cancels-speech-by-breitbrart-writer-milo-amid-intense-protests/?tid=a_inl&utm_term=.64eabcdb58ac

Sonia Martinez Uncivil Discource

Sonia Martinez

Soc. 3

T. Kubal

May 7, 2017

Uncivil Discourse

                The article in my opinion is harmful and is not harmful; it really just depends on how you look at it and how you feel towards it. With times like these it is hard to not think wrong of others and be so judgmental. You need a really good understanding before making the right decisions. Sometimes we all get caught up in the moment and don't think about we did until once it's happened. Uncivil discourse is a problem in this country because we have people viewing situations from different points of view. No matter how civil we try to be there will always be someone around us that is uncivil. Lately situations have been getting a bit out of hand and people are resulting in committing crime to express how they feel. I don't think that is right at all. Uncivil discourse I think isn't a problem until people begin to get violent and begin to do things that are illegal or inhumane.

                This past NFL season Colin Kaepernick had the world talking about him. He did something no one else had in the NFL history. He chose to kneel down during the National Anthem. I personally think that it was good that he stood up in a peaceful way not in a crazy violent way. After all we do have the right of doing as we please and for him being a well known athlete and doing this, it got to a lot of fans and people were with and against him. In the article, Colin Kaepernick is a Patriot, the author brings to our attention that in the United States communities of color have suffered more. "In Kaepernick's case it is both a sign of respect and a sign of protest. And I think it's incredibly elegant. If I understand the situation correctly, he had been kneeling for several weeks before the media picked up on it. He did it silently and on his own. A quiet respectful way of enacting both of our most deeply held beliefs: the freedom to protest the lack of equality in a nation that imagines itself as the most egalitarian place on earth." I agree with the author that it was both a sign of respect and a sign of protest.

                After Colin was brave enough to do this, other celebrities started following along. There are so much different cases happening daily and all people want is equality for all. But how can we be equal if there is so much discrimination, I honestly don't know because the discrimination hasn't stopped and unfortunately I don't think that discrimination will ever end. It is sad to say but some people can't be happy if they choose to live in a world full of hate and discrimination against innocent people. I hope that one day things get better and we really cut down on the hate crimes and discrimination as a whole in society. 

Election Attacks on Candidates

Jordan Lee

Timothy Kulbal

Soc 3

4 May 2017

Uncivil Discourse: Election Attacks on Candidates

Uncivil discourse, uncivil discourse is still in our society today and people see it all the time. Uncivil discourse to me is the use of language in an improper manner. It is the use of unmannered words, hate and language, it is not the way to have a conversation on a topic, to get your opinion across, it is not a conversation when people use uncivil discourse. The most common use of uncivil discourse to me was in the 2016 election, mainly pertaining to Donald Trump and other candidates. Trump used inappropriate tactics at the other candidates running for presidency, it was the most common uncivil discourse that people had seen.

The uncivil discourse did not just happen from one person, it happened within every candidate and party. People from the same party would use psat information, hateful words into their campaign to make themselves look better when that is not the way to show you can be a president, using argumentative words is not the way to have a conversation to people. One incident that is mainly known is when candidate Donald Trump attacked other candidate Marco Rubio, Trump said, "I mean, Marco Rubio, as an example. He's got no money, zero. Now, I think that's OK, (but) ... I mean, he's got nothing," (Washington CNN). Donald Trump also went after Rubio's self appearance, "(Rubio) announced he was going to run because he's overly ambitious, too young -- and I have better hair than he does, right?", Trump attacked his self appearance and how he speaks about himself, Trump did this to make himself look better than his other candidates pointing out their flaws when actually Trump is using uncivil discourse to get ahead of the election, (Washington CNN). By attacking his other candidates is wrong, it's not the way to speak about other people, it's not a proper conversation.

This shows that Trump used uncivil discourse, it was harsh and unmannered, he attacked people to get his point across instead of speaking highly and respectfully to get his way in. Uncivil discourse needs to end, it doesn't get the person anywhere when using this type of tactic. People need to realize there are better ways to speak on something. Uncivil discourse does not get people anywhere, only to lead to unhappy endings.


Work Cited

Kopan, Tal. "Donald Trump Attacks Marco Rubio." CNN. Cable News Network, 23 Sept. 2015. Web. 08 May 2017. URL. <.http://www.cnn.com/2015/09/23/politics/donald-trump-marco-rubio-south-carolina/ >.

Vanessa Naranjo Uncivil Discourse

Vanessa Naranjo

Uncivil Discourse

Uncivil discourse is definitely harmful to society. It usually consists of what is called "hate speech" and can sometimes turn extremely violent. It is evident that this type of behavior needs to stop. However, a lot of us have become used to seeing all these types of incidents in the media. Whether it be the riots that took place at UC Berkeley over a conservative guest, or even something more extreme, such as a hate crime shooting. Uncivil discourse is harmful because it puts us at risk of becoming victims of a hate crime. I believe that the riots that occurred at UC Berkeley were absolutely ridiculous, because conservatives should still be able to express their opinion, regardless of who else agrees. Instead of forming riots, why not have a meaningful debate about different points of view? I definitely believe in freedom of speech, and the ability of expressing ourselves to others. However, it is different once someone decides to discriminate against someone else because of different ideologies, or different skin color or religion. That is what I have a problem with.

For example, a news article from Washington's Top News titled "Jewish community reacts to spike in religious hate crimes" talks about the rise of hate crimes, particularly against the Jewish community.  According to the article, in Montgomery County, there seems to be more anti-Semitic hate crimes than any other type of hate crime, despite Jews making up only 3.1 percent of the population. The most common type of hate crime reported against the Jewish community was vandalism and graffiti. In public restrooms and public recreation areas, many swastikas have been noted. This cannot be considered freedom of speech, since it is obviously hurting the Jewish community. This type of hate seems to stem from the Holocaust, which is one of the most tragic hate crimes that has occurred. Jews in Montgomery have every right to be comfortable in their neighborhood without feeling fearful or threatened. We should be focusing more on these types of hate crimes, instead of trying to censor a conservative author.

 

 

News Article Link

http://wtop.com/montgomery-county/2017/04/jewish-community-reacts-to-spike-in-religious-hate-crimes/

Brittany Clegg Uncivil discourse through politics


Brittany Clegg
Argumentative essay – uncivil discourse
5/7/2107
Sociology 3 – Monday 11am

One of the simplest ways to talk about current events which represent uncivil discourse would be to talk about the Donald Trump tweets. The article from a web news site titled "Donald Trump's most controversial tweets since becoming president" showcase all the negative and careless ideas that he is putting on the internet for the whole world to see. These comments are not how world leaders usually respond to situations and, instead, instill fear and uncertainty into the minds of both the nation and the world. The article outlines some of the most controversial tweets that Trump has tweeted in his first 100 days as President of the United States. The first example is his tweet which read "Terrible! Just found out that Obama had my "wires tapped" in Trump Tower just before the victory. Nothing found. This is McCarthyism!" Not only was this in the middle of the night, but there was no solid evidence to prove this claim. Another one of the tweets reads "I have tremendous respect for women and the many roles they serve that are vital to the fabric of our society and our economy" which is very controversial to the claims that he made during his campaign where women were constantly degraded. Many of his comments contradict each other which makes his presidency that much more questionable.
In my opinion, uncivil discourse is extremely harmful. Aspects of uncivil discourse such as hate speech are the very thing that is tearing the country apart, making others think it is okay to hate on others which unravels in a huge chain reaction. It is true that hate speech cannot be completely banned for that would be violating the right to free speech, but it should not be advocated by people such as the President of the United States or people running for that position. If there is any hope for the rebuilding of the nation and solving problems of inequality and race, it is through the advocating of open-mindedness and acceptance among all people. This is what will bring people together, not being uncivil with one another. So, it should not be banned, but it should be largely frowned upon.