Tuesday, May 2, 2017

Carmen Esqueda: Uncivil Discourse

I am not for or against uncivil discourse because it has been going on for decades.  However, now that it poses a huge controversy among all the American people and different cultures within the U.S. I have an opinion.  The negative part of uncivil discourse causes harm to those trying to make a positive change.  For instance, the so-called protest that turn in to riots or damaging businesses and verbally or physically harming others.  How can society take those people serious are hear rioters out when that goes against what free speech initially was meant to be for.  Sometimes information is released or mentioned in return the people the story was about get harassed.  For some reason some people feel it is okay to verbally abuse people for saying what is on their mind or information about them is put out for all to see.  However, government has become so consumed with shutting down anyone or anything expressing truthful issues.  Then some people get so offended from a simple opinion or a peaceful protest that does not coincide with what they stand for or believe in.  I do not believe things will change if there is consequences handed out for negative or offensive free speech.  Some people feel so strongly about their beliefs that they will accept the consequences or just do not care what happens.  Those who do care just might simply stay quite and keep their opinions to themselves because they feel it is not worth getting involved or things will not change.  If anything, free speech will eventually be obsolete at the rate the government is working to take just about all our American rights away.     

Article

Editor: Mayor refuses responsibility for uncivil discourse he incited

            From what I gather, the article visits the fact that a Bastrop counsel member filed a complaint against the other counsel members that involved the mayor.  Information was given out about a case, which is against code.  In addition, a comment was made about the person that filed the complaints.  However, nothing was done and no one was fired.  If anything, the counsel member that filed the complaint is the one dealing with drama.  He was talked about and made out to be the bad person for initially filing the complaint.  This is a good example of how leaking information can be used against someone and bring about negative uncivil discourse or trying to do the right thing leads to negative behavior from others.  


http://www.statesman.com/news/local/editor-mayor-refuses-responsibility-for-uncivil-discourse-incited/h5ZYDBJQpLgV8GXaMKYJSO/

Sonia Martinez Extra Credit Sociology 3 MW 9-9:50

I attended the three sessions for the 15 points.

Laura Rodriguez, Uncivil discourse

Laura Rodriguez

Uncivil discourse

http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2017/04/19/frank-artiles-florida-state-senator-apologizes-for-racial-slurs.html

 

            Uncivil discourses leave the audience retaliating against racial injustice speeches. There are two main political parties, therefore there will always be disagreements. There will always be one dissatisfied party. Have you heard of the saying, "If you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all?" This was a lesson taught to us in preschool and repeatedly mentioned throughout grade school.

            There will always be those who feel overly powerful to want to step on those who are inferior in their eyes. These people will use their position and political status to voice their discourse without thinking of the consequences. There are some people that can walk away with it and not be shunned by their conflicting words. This type of discourse can only stir trouble among the citizens affected.

            I agree that as American citizens we have the right to practice freedom and speech. We have the right to exercise our rights but in a positive and appropriate manner, you're more likely to be heard.  The negative and racial slurs only lead to racial hatred and crimes that were demonstrated in this type of discourse.

A great example of a uncivil discourse is demonstrated by the Republican senator of Tallahassee, Florida, Frank Articles. He was caught and reported for using offensive racial slurs. How did he assume that his words would not be seen as offensive. At the time, the people in the room did not walk away and turn their heads. He is a public figure, a senator, but this does not give him the right to publicly offend and discriminate against another race. He must have felt he was invisible.   What else is the Florida Legislative expecting from him since his 3 minute apology wasn't enough. He's surely not the first to run his mouth in an offensive manner, will he be the first to lose his seat for it. There have been much greater accusations in higher positions that have been at stake yet you see them stationed in their positions. First of all, he wasn't thinking about the position he holds when he orally discriminated and the consequences that could follow. There's a time and place to relieve your emotions and vent, it certainly wasn't at the time of work when surrounded by colleagues at a meeting!

 

Rocio Chavez, Uncivil Discourse Affecting Schools

Rocio Chavez

Soc. 111

2 May 2017

Uncivil Discourse

                Many of us are aware of our right to free speech and are activist for it when it comes to something we are passionate about. I believe that in several of these cases, people use their freedom to represent and empower positive movements in society. But at the same time, there are few people who use this freedom to cause harm to others. Uncivil discourse is like a double edge sword, it alleviates stress and anger for some by arguing their side on a topic but can cause devastating results for the other side.           

                There is not a direct way to solve uncivil discourse in society without hindering a person's freedom of speech. It seems like the correct way to "deal" with an act of uncivil discourse should be through the legal system and jail time. If one were to have to censor their actual thoughts and concerns then there would not be progress made. Half of the battle is telling others our concerns in hopes to spark change whether it be positive or negative.

                An article that highlighted the effects and problems due to uncivil discourse was posted in the PBS News Hour today was "Teachers not shying away from divisive political discussion…" The article focused on Kindergarten through 12th-grade teachers and how there has been high amounts of uncivil discourse in school since the Presidential Election of 2016. In the article, many teachers stated feeling an uneasy atmosphere change between their students. There were more reported cases of bullying and students with undocumented family members were afraid for their safety. In addition, many teachers reported avoiding controversial issue in order to maintain the classroom neutrality while others chose to embrace the chaos and have it serve as a lesson too. After reading this, I was astonished that uncivil discourse can even impact the lives of innocent children and cause them anxiety. The topic of uncivil discourse is unpredictable


Sergio Cortez; Uncivil Discourse

Sergio Cortez
Mr. Kubal
Sociology 111
2 May 2017

Uncivil Discourse
    This topic has been around for a very long time now, and it clearly does not seem that it will cease to exist. It is safe to say that uncivil discourse is occurring every hour of the day all year round. This is also affecting those who fall victims to this kind of behavior, and a lot of individuals suggest that this is all part of our right to practice freedom of speech when in reality it isn't. If you take an individual who is being verbally abused by another individual with death threats, and racial slurs how can others just respond by saying that it isn't wrong at all? It is clearly a problem and there should be consequences for this kind of behavior because there have been a lot of instances where you have these individuals who fall victim to this kind of tragedy and they do not take it very lightly in some cases. To be more specific there have been many times where individuals act out with violence. If jail time or even fees for committing such crime were to be introduced it really wouldn't work out in all honesty. Uncivil discourse will remain behind closed doors and won't be able to be enforced as strictly as it should be.
If we look at the article titled, "Teachers not shying away from divisive political discussion, survey suggests" , by Madeline Will we notice that she includes details on how the past year election in November between Trump and Clinton had a great affect in schools all across the country. Ever since Trump had won the election there has been an increase in the number of bullying incidents that occurred in school which were connected to things such as race, and religion. Tensions have basically risen and school environments have fallen victim to this kind of behavior. As we continue on with Madeline's article we come across a sentence where she states that a teacher at a middle school in New Mexico actually heard a student threaten another fellow student by saying that President Trump would deport the student's father back to where he came from. To be completely real with the situation this is not at all right. The young student who was victimized in this case is just one of many who suffer the same experience. Individuals are basically being targeted for the mere color of their skin, or religion.
To sum everything up uncivil discourse has been affecting the lives of many for who knows how long. It is something that will continue to exist no matter which way the public tries to find means of eliminating it. It has always been around in this country, but the election has caused a spark to come up and individuals true feelings are beginning to erupt as a result of all this.



Monday, May 1, 2017

Marlene Alcantar Uncivil Discourse

 

Marlene Alcantar

Sociology 111

Uncivil Discourse

There are some people in this world who say hatful things and get away with it easily. Simply calling people some hateful names is one thing, but threatening their lives is far worse and this leads to violence. Words are just as powerful as actions. I believe that someone's words who are threatening to others should be detained and punished for it. They should at least be investigated to find out if they actually meant what they said. Someone people say things and don't actually mean them, but most of the time they do. I think there are many causes of these hate speeches. I think the most important cause of this, is the media. Media is the main cause of these hate speeches because a lot of the news articles appear on there and most of them are false and make people think otherwise. This causes people to express how they feel about certain situations on the news, which leads to people threatening others and causing hate speeches. I feel that a person should never put their political opinions online anywhere because there is always going to be someone who has different views from you. Everyone is allowed to have their own opinions of topics. However, I think that there should be certain limits or guidelines as to what they are allowed to say on the internet. Especially because the government is always watching and can easily charge you if you happen to threaten or harm anyone's life.                                                                                                              In the article "Civility and Public Discourse", by Ean Maloney on April 28, 2017, he talks about a letter written to the editor in response to a previously published opinion piece. In that letter, there was a statement that really stood out. This statement said, "It will always be a painful truth that there are people out there like you, [Ms./Mr. so and so], who oppose the right to [such and such].". In this statement, Ean points out that this could also mean, "The earth would be a better place if you were not a living inhabitant". Words have an infinite way of creating different kinds of meanings. It all depends on how the person reading their opinion analyzes it in their own perspective.                                                                                                                               URL: http://ndsmcobserver.com/2017/04/civility-public-discourse/

 

 

Sent from Mail for Windows 10

 

Collin Hayes Uncivil Discourse

Collin Hayes

Soc 3, Timothy Kubal

Uncivil Discourse



Almost all good things in life have their downsides. Food can lead you to be obese, partying can lead you to getting a DUI, School can lead to a loss of sleep, and the freedom of speech can lead to some words others may not wish to hear. Uncivil discourse is a topic that is very controversial because it is seen as a problem which can lead to violence. However solutions for stopping uncivil discourse may involve altering or limiting our freedom of speech which is granted in the first amendment of the United States constitution. Freedom of speech, just like everything and anything will have it's downsides, in this case uncivil discourse. Uncivil discourse is not harmful, however it is the interpretations of it that can make it harmful, not the uncivil discourse itself. Uncivil discourse is everywhere however, in TV shows, movies, school, and our government.

One article called "Can Post-2016 Politics Become More Respectful?" by Alison St John and Michael lipkin touches on the issue of uncivil discourse. The article argues that the previous presidential election in 2016 displayed the "nastiest" communication among politics due to rude tweets and name-calling becoming a norm without debate. The article concludes that one reason we are seeing this happen is because attention is going to those who are uncivil. The proposed solution by the article is to inform upcoming state legislatures on how act respectfully and civil. John and Lipkin support this by informing about workshops held at UC San Diego which are intended to create a more positive and respectful political environment.

It is true that people tend to pay attention to people who are involved with something which is uncivil. Think about the news stories which are usually most popular, is it the ones that involved someone who gave a beautiful speech about something they love that you think of, or is it about someone who disrespected or said something which targeted something or someone negatively. If you're like most people it would have been the disrespectful and negative speech which would be heard more frequently. John and Lipkin support this idea in their writing by saying that people pay attention to the things which are uncivil. Similarly, we often pay attention to the negative things in the news, rather than the positive things. Most likely, people would be more interested and create a bigger conversation about a bombing in Syria, rather than a cure for some deadly disease. If this doesn't make it clear that we think of negatives more than positives, think of as many negative events as you can that have happened in the world this year, then think of all of the positive events.

Uncivil discourse isn't necessarily harmful. The old phrase, sticks and stones may break my bones but words will never hurt me is relative in this case. First we have to define what uncivil discourse is, uncivil meaning discourteous or impolite and discourse meaning written of spoken communication. Now obviously, there is going to be some communication that we find impolite or not courteous. However the extent of this rests upon the individual, because we all have different beliefs on what is polite and impolite. Which makes the idea of keeping our freedom of speech untampered with critical. We all have different ideas and eventually someone will disagree with them no matter what, because we all have different views. We should not judge someone else's view because it is different than ours.

Someone might say that Trump is a person who has displayed uncivil discourse by saying that he has tweeted things such as fake media this and that, or that Obama has spied on him. This matter may be different, since Trump is not an ordinary citizen, so maybe matters should differentiate upon our leaders in government and society. Another example would be the teacher at Fresno State who made death threats and created a conspiracy where people believe that he inspired the murder of four white men. He is also a leader in society, he is a teacher at a university who many people look up to. The point being made here, is that the uncivil discourse made by these people are not causing any violence, it is the people who are committing the violence who are causing the violence. For instance, we see horror movies all the time, but most likely we don't leave the movie theater ready to kill people and exercise what the movie has shown. If we did, that would be our own choice and probably due to a mental disability.

If we are careful who we elect as our leaders in our local community, our society and our government, we won't have to worry about uncivil discourse in the first place. Free speech should never be limited because we all have our own views on what is right and wrong, what's important what's not, and what our purpose is. Uncivil discourse is just a fancy word for a listener who is not pleased with what they have heard. Some of the best things in life have their downsides, just like our beloved freedom of speech. Uncivil discourse, or impolite communication is something we deal with everyday, and it is just a part of life.



References:

Article:

Can Post-2016 Politics Become More Respectful? by Alison St John and Michael lipkin

Can Post-2016 Politics Become More Respectful? | KPBS



Kristina Packard, Uncivil Discourse and how it is bad

Kristina Packard

Sociology 111

1 May 2017

Uncivil Discourse how it is bad

    Uncivil Discourse is when a person is when someone speaks about a certain subject to the public. It is not smart to threaten a president on the internet while others can see it. It can be taken in the wrong way and people will think that the person is sending out death threats that can put someone in danger. It is very harmful to send death threats to someone especially if it is to someone of political power. That person can be sent to jail or seen as a terrorist for say something that they shouldn't on the internet. Inequality could also be a big factor for people doing crimes and threatening others because they feel like they are not being treated fairly or not getting enough attention from others. If a person is threatening our nation or the life of another person then they should have to answer to that and should be put in jail or should at least be investigated to make sure that there is no harm being done. If a person is just saying something on their mind then maybe another person can just take it the wrong way but people have to be careful when they post things on the internet. The article that helps support this argument is, "Redeeming our Uncivil Discourse," by Scott Slayton on March 8, 2016. He talks about how political people do a lot of name calling on each other. People do not think before they start speaking. He talks about when he was helping count votes and they told who won lots of  people were shouting out for them to recount because they didn't like who won. The people that did do the counting were getting in trouble because the people in charge believed that they cheated on the voting counts. He also talks about how there are consequences for people who lie and do not tell the truth.

URL: http://www.scottslayton.net/2016/03/08/redeeming-uncivil-discourse/