Wednesday, May 3, 2017

Sandy Vongthong/ Uncivil Discourse

 

Sandy Vongthong

Professor Kubal

Soc 111

May 2, 2017

 

Uncivil Discourse 

There is a thin line between uncivil discourse and Freedom of Speech. Freedom of Speech is apart of our constitution and is designed to protect actions and speech. For instance, the KKK can hold events in public places and speak about their beliefs against other minority groups and as long as they are not breaking the law the KKK have the rights to express their own viewpoints. While the Freedom of Speech allows individuals to "freely" voice our opinions, there are still restrictions that applies to the law. According to www.uscourts.gov, the First Amendment limit individuals from provoking actions that may cause injury to others such as yelling "fire" in a crowded movie theater, these types of regulations along with other restrictions are put in place in order to protect individuals.

Similar to the set limitations in Freedom of Speech, uncivil discourse should have some boundaries. For instance, in the article, Just how uncivil is Election 2016? MIT's Media Lab has some charts you should see, written by Timothy McGrath of the GlobalPost, explains the negative consequences of uncivil discourse. The article was particularly referring to the 2016 election where several of the candidates including Hilary Clinton, Donald Trump, and other running mates were bashing one another on social media and not to mention some of the commits were rude and disrespectful. As the candidates, humiliated themselves on social media, they failed to grasp the impact of their message and the influence it has on the public. During the social media battle with one another, their actions escalated tension among the different groups of supports and resulted in riots and violence. In one situation, Donald Trump had to cancel his trip to Chicago as the conflict between demonstrators and advocators grew out of hand. Public figures and leaders hold a certain responsibility and should be aware of their actions as it could have many negative consequences. Furthermore, I feel individuals are also held responsible for their own actions. While people should have the freedom to speak their minds, I believe misinformation or advocating for violence which can result in people getting hurt is unethical and should not be tolerated.


References:

 

https://www.pri.org/stories/2016-04-29/just-how-uncivil-election-2016-mits-media-lab-has-some-charts-you-should-see

 

http://www.uscourts.gov/about-federal-courts/educational-resources/about-educational-outreach/activity-resources/what-does

Jessica Alva Uncivil Discourse

Jessica Alva

Mr. Kubal

Sociology 111                       

3 May 2017

Uncivil Discourse

"You have the right to free speech as long as you're not dumb enough to actually try it."- Know Your Rights by The Clash this quote is very true. People feel like they are able to say anything that comes to their mind but you really have to think about it "is it worth it". The professor here at Fresno State just wanted to get things out of his mind, he probably thought his comments wouldn't have been a big deal but it was and because of his so called freedom of speech he lost his job. In this article it states that they believe the professor and the mass murder who killed 4 males must have been a relationship between both of them due to their intention of why had he decide to kill the four male days after the professor had sent out his comments about the president. People say they are ok with freedom of speech but when it comes to it being racist or offensive they make a big deal about it then why be pro to freedom of speech if you will be offended by it. Social media really likes to mix up their information I have always thought that in videos people usually only record the part where they see injustice but don't record from the beginning what if there was more to it.

         Making America whole again via Civics Education by Chris Bedrik, This article can be relatable to what happening in most schools whether it's in elementary, middle school, high school and even in college. Kids wants to talk about politics but does the teacher really want to what if their freedom of speech get them in trouble with the child parent because he or she spoke up about politics. It is very dangerous but the children do need to know what's happening in the world. "One thing that came out of our research is that students are fascinated by the fact that their peers have different opinions," she said. "It opens them up to the idea that the world is complex, that people don't all think like me, and I still like these people." This quote had an impact in me, because students to want to have that politic talk, but are afraid to open up about their own belief but they need to know that it is ok for people to have their own belief they are still going to care about the other person. They just wont have the same things in common.

 

http://hechingerreport.org/making-america-whole-via-civics-education/    

Kara Wright - Uncivil Discourse

 

 

Kara Wright – Uncivil Discourse – Article: "The death of civil discourse: Twitterverse eviscerates Bret Stephens over climate column" http://thehill.com/blogs/pundits-blog/media/331310-the-death-of-civil-discourse-twitterverse-eviscerates-bret-stephens 

            Uncivil Discourse has become a widely-discussed issue in our country recently. Uncivil is defined as the lack of civility or good manners and discourse is defined as written or spoken communication or a debate. When you put these two words together you get the idea of people communicating about issue uncivilly. Many times, uncivil discourse seems to spark from a bold statement. The question stated is whether uncivil discourse is harmful or not and I think that there are definite times where it can be harmful, but I also think that sometimes there is nothing wrong with it. An example of uncivil discourse where there was nothing wrong with it, is the article I will discuss. In the article, "The death of civil discourse: Twitterverse eviscerates Bret Stephens over climate column" is discusses a man named Bret Stephens and why he is very hated right now. He is a writer for the New York Times and he is hated for being realistic about climate change and sticking to one side. The things Bret Stephens has said regarding the climate has cause much hated tweets and things to be. In a tweet by Bret Stephens is says, "After 20 months of being harangued by bullying Trump supporters, I'm reminded that the nasty left is no different, perhaps worse". The article he wrote caused many people to cancel their subscriptions to the New York Times. I think that in this instance that Stephens is just saying something that people don't what to hear and its causing an uproar, but I don't think that there is anything wrong or harmful about it. With saying that, in other instances I think that it can be very harmful. There must be a line of what is okay to say and what is not, but that gray area seems to just be getting larger.

Kamaldeep Kaur- Political Speech

Kamaldeep Kaur

Timothy Kubal

Race of Sociology

May 3, 2017

Uncivil Discourse

Uncivil discourse can be considered a form for people to use certain rhetoric to further one's own argument and message. It usually involves actions that are considered provocative, obscene, yet at times thought provoking. Most times I believe when certain rhetoric is called out by the media as 'uncivil discourse,' they are right, however, I also believe the conversation can be taken out of context. In such, I do believe uncivil discourse is harmful to an affluent and society that needs to work together, however, not all provocative statement made by someone on topics such as social, and political movements should be considered a form of 'uncivil discourse.'

In an article by Staci Matlock of The Tao News, A fresh perspective: 'Where has common decency gone?' individuals are discussing how Governor Martinez's speech involved forms of inflammatory rhetoric. It was considered that instead of her talking about ways to improve the state of New Mexico, she used 'slurs' such as 'liar' and 'disgrace.' The governors entire speech was rendered as 'uncivil discourse.' But why is it that one decides to use a few particular words that are ultimately used by everyone, everyday to communicate with one another deemed as evil or obscene. Ultimately, the community in which the speech was presented to did not even give her an opportunity to view the message behind the speech. Therefore, it is essential to understand the rhetoric used by individuals and the meaning behind it so it is not taken out of context and considered as uncivil discourse. I believe free speech should allow us to be thought provoking, and even provocative and it provokes a good debate, however, it should be done in good taste.

http://www.taosnews.com/stories/a-fresh-perspective-where-has-common-decency-gone,39965

BiancaMartinez Uncivil discourse

UNCIVIL DISCOURSE

Uncivil discourse can be both a good thing and a bad thing. This is due to it being a way for individuals to speak their minds without having to go out and do those things. Because of this reason, I believe uncivil discourse is not always a negative, but can be seen as a way for individuals who are unhappy with society to express themselves. It can lead to healthy ways for individuals to express themselves, if done properly, such as civil discourse. In the news article, 'Teachers not Shying Away from Divisive Political Discussion', it focuses on the topic of civil discourse in the classroom. According to the information given, most teachers try not to shy away from political types of discussions. This is due to them wanting students to be able to express themselves correctly. If a teacher can model proper civil discourse, the students can learn how to do it properly, rather than just spewing ignorance and hate. In the case of uncivil discourse, these teachers modeling good civil discourse can teach the students how to discuss politics in a way that will not offend others or call for violence. The article mentions that these students don't always receive proper information when it comes to politics, so they take it as their jobs to make sure students are properly informed. Uncivil discourse can be channelled in a different way, such as civil discourse. Uncivil discourse can lead to negative consequences because one never know who will see or hear what is said, or even how individuals will act. The article presented a positive alternative to uncivil discourse, which should be considered greatly over uncivil discourse.


http://www.pbs.org/newshour/updates/teachers-not-shying-away-divisive-political-discussion-survey-suggests/

Lorena Rangel- Expressing feelings without imposing threat


Heather Lewis Uncivil Discourse

Heather Lewis

SOC-111

May 2, 2017

Uncivil Discourse

            Uncivil discourse is going to be around for a long time and most likely will get worst because of various reasons such as the media blaring almost nonstop about what is going on in the U.S. that a lot of people are resorting to speaking of violence and resorting to violence as well. I believe that uncivil discourse is not something that should be anywhere near using free speech and I believe that it is very harmful to those who hear it, witness it and even say it. The media uses the people who want to voice their concerns about various things that suggest when a person is trying to voice their concerns their emotions get the better of them and they say and do things that do not belong in a civil conversation or protest. The different kinds of speech deserves the right to not turn into something violent or using speech to push their own words that involve some ones death into a speech they spread to everyone especially when the media loves to hear so much people going about hating others for various reasons of their own. Some things that could be done to maybe get away from uncivil discourse is that maybe the people should look at all of the different sides that are involved in the discussion or protest while trying to put their own emotions away from the desire to do something or say something harmful.

            In an article that I read called "Pundits: Political discourse at all-time low" by Shawn K. Wickham is about talking on how uncivil discourse is escalating to the point where there is more than there was before the election of 2016 before the current President of the U.S. Trump was named. The author talks about how the media and other outlets want the escalation of uncivil discourse to continue because they thrive on all of the violence that speech has caused so much animosity towards those that they dislike in which the article also talks about how several people from politics are fed up with all of the speeches that end up being thrown out of proportion by several factors such as the media. The people who the author comments on suggest that they are those that want to find a way to stop the uncivil discourse with speech such as hate speech. Towards the end the author asks the person who they are talking to about a few ways to have them change in which they respond with that people need to start listening to others around them and see their side on how they view things to get a better understanding in which I faintly said something similar. In the end there are things that could help people not use uncivil discourse when talking or expressing their views, but the hard part is that people tend to get overridden by their own emotions which they do not think about what they are saying until it is already said especially when it comes to the media that it feels that it wants to exploit uncivil discourse for whatever reasons the media has.

 

http://www.unionleader.com/voters-first/Pundits-Political-discourse-at-all-time-low-08282016

Tuesday, May 2, 2017

Avelina Charles Uncivil Discourse

Uncivil Discourse

Uncivil discourse is very harmful, and the ramifications of uncivil discourse can be detrimental. Even though racism has never truly died, open racism was frowned upon for a brief time. Unfortunately, since our celebrity president announced the basis he was running his campaign on hate crimes have been rising at an alarming rate. I do believe in freedom of speech, and what it is meant to represent. However, I do not agree with anyone who spews ignorance and fear as a tactic to control. If we live in a country that holds civilians, including professors accountable for what they say then why not do the same for our government. I understand that the media loves situations like these, and they eat it up. Still, the media cannot make up everything that comes out of the current president's mouth, or his crew. I say "crew" because the way government is acting is no different than a street gang. Their thug like tactics resulting in hate crimes and fear. Using force to target certain groups, and dividing a nation that's claim to fame is "United We Stand".

In the article "Workplace Political Tensions Persist in Trump's First 100 Days", written by Genevieve Douglas addresses the inevitable tension that is rising in the workplace do to political differences. There is an excessive amount of hyper-vigilance, in return employees are less productive due to discomfort. The Equal Employment Opportunity program recommends in house training, and counseling available for employees who are being victimized by acts of bigotry. There is a focus on being careful what is being said at the workplace. This brings up the same question, if limiting and censoring content is violating the right of freedom to speak.

Article: https://www.bna.com/workplace-political-tensions-n57982087295/