Monday, February 13, 2017

Essay on Two Refugee Articles - Zachary Riggins

The first of my two articles by the Chicago Tribune details the Congregations that hosted pro-refugee gatherings in Highland Park and Buffalo Grove. Rabbi Evan Moffic spoke in his Highland Park Synagogue about the importance of welcoming immigrants and refugees in the United States, referencing the citations in the Hebrew Bible highlighting the importance of welcoming the stranger into your community. When Trump signed the executive order banning travel from those Muslim-majority countries, Moffic was reminded of the American government's refusal to accept German Jews who were trying to get away from Nazi Germany in 1939. U.S. Rep. Brad Schneider (D-Deerfield) spoke out as well, saying that while it is important for the vetting process of individuals applying for refugee status to be strong, it is even more vital for us not to close our borders to anyone for their religious beliefs.


The second of my two articles by BBC news was a specific example of two migrants seeking refugee status in Canada. Seidu Mohammad and Razak Iyal were faced with deportation back to Ghana after they were denied refugee status in the United States. They tried to venture into Manitoba and were nearly killed by hypothermia had it not been for the residents who had given them hospitality. Their fingers were frozen into claw-like position and they had to get most of them amputated due to the frostbite. This story isn't a new phenomenon but it has shed light on a recently growing issue of migrants seeking refuge in Canada due to the refusal by the American government.


The issue of immigration and refugees has divided many people here in the United States – as seen especially in the polls provided in professor Kubal's essay. One side of the argument is generally more distrustful and wants little to do with refugees. They claim that a more strict vetting process of immigrants strengthens national security in the looming threat of terrorism. Some on this side would venture to argue that a full-on travel ban is necessary in certain countries. Is their distrust justifiable by evidence of terrorism, or is it perhaps based on messages of fear spread by politicians to further their agendas? As professor Kubal cited in his essay, their argument might be more valid in European nations than in the United States – the United States has had no significant amount of occurrences of terrorism by refugees.


The other side of the argument states that we should be more welcoming of immigrants and refugees because we are a nation founded by immigrants and refugees. They claim that we shouldn't discriminate against people by religion when it comes to allowing people into our country. On top of that, it has been cited that there hasn't been a significant amount of terrorism committed by refugees for it to be as big of an issue as modern politicians may have the public otherwise believe. Another point to this argument is that overly strong vetting or banning of immigration may end up motivating these terrorist organizations. Is their concern on preserving American core values to accept immigrants applicable today, or might America end up more like those European nations that have faced a recently increased amount of riots due to their supposed problems with immigration if it were to allow a certain amount of refugees in?

3 comments:

  1. That is an interesting point you discussed regarding terrorist organizations potentially becoming motivated by this executive order since it is targeting specific countries. I think that this refugee ban can further lead to disagreements occurring amongst the nations that are being banned and the United States which can have effects on commerce. The issue the author is discussing is President Trump's refugee ban and whether or not America should continue to accept immigrants into the country. The author presents a strong argument and reasonable claims by addressing both sides of this controversy. This allows the reader to know both sides of the issue rather than only hearing one side and framing their opinion.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with Japneet Riggins's argument was stronger because it acknowledged competing sides to the story. An argument is almost always stronger if it acknowledges its opponent.

    ReplyDelete
  3. You include a question to leave the reader with a thought but fail to provide a true conclusion. It is evident you are discussing the current issue of refugees and you do a good job at providing evidence BBC news.

    ReplyDelete