An article from npr.org discussed how President Trump's executive order on immigration has caused uncertainty for the United States. It highlighted the two provisions that the federal appeals court did not directly rule out. First, they did not address the issue of how decreasing the number of refugees would cut the refugee quota for the 2017 fiscal year by over 50 percent. The second provision that was not addressed was how states and cities could veto refugee placements more easily. As of right now, there is a halt on Trump's ban, thanks to refugee advocates. Before the ban, there was an organized way of coordinating refugees through state and local officials. However, all of that has changed due to Trump's actions. Their jobs have become more challenging when having to face refugees and not being able to allow them. It might also make agencies reassess their systems to meet the new requirements. Many officials are unhappy with the President's actions, especially since there is absolutely no evidence to support that the refugees are terrorists.
The second article, titled, "Are Refugees Dangerous?" discussed the links between refugee populations and crime in the U.S. President Trump's reasoning for his refugee ban was for the safety of the people and our nation. However, whenever he discusses terrorist attacks (i.e. San Bernardino and Orlando), they do not support his argument because these never involved refugees. Using data from the Partnership for a New American Economy, the article highlights fact-based evidence on refugees and crime. This study showed that the increased number of refugees in cities actually resulted in a decreased crime rate, indicating a high correlation between the two. On the other side, since 2015, four refugees were arrested on terrorism-related charges. Two of the four were from countries on Trump's list. Only two of the 69,000+ refugees that year were found guilty, and the majority of refugees fail to exhibit any acts of terrorism plotting in the U.S., which cripples Trump's argument.
Works Cited
Amos, D. (2017, February 13). For Refugees And Advocates, Trump Immigration Order Stay
Leads To Disarray. Retrieved February 15, 2017, from http://www.npr.org/sections/parallels/2017/02/13/514966051/for-refugees-and-advocates-trump-immigration-order-stay-leads-to-disarray.
Misra, T. (2017, February 14). The Real Link Between Crime and Refugees. Retrieved February
15, 2017, from http://www.citylab.com/crime/2017/02/refugee-resettlement-v-crime/516471/.
I like the elements you pointed out in each article, it seems as though you read the articles with a critical eye to see whether they were reliable or not. You presented both perspectives of the issue in each article which I enjoyed reading. You did good in explaining main points of the article and by not including your own opinion.
ReplyDeleteGavin Jepma: I thoroughly enjoyed this article. Especially with the issues raised in our society as they compare to historical facts. Moreover, the historical perspective is imperative to understanding social issues, especially when they have been repeated. Good read!
ReplyDelete